Preview Extract
This document contains Chapters 13 to 14 CHAPTER 13 Your External and Internal Customers Review Questions 1. Explain what it means to say that customers really want feelings and solutions, rather than products and services. When you are a customer, what does that mean to you? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Customers buy only two things—good feelings and solutions to problems. Everything that a customer wants will fall into one of these two categories. For example, a customer doesn’t buy just clothes. He or she buys a sharp appearance, style, attractiveness, comfort, and warmth. When we say that customers want feelings and solutions rather than just products and services, we're emphasizing the emotional and practical aspects of their purchasing decisions. 1. Feelings: Customers often seek experiences that resonate with them emotionally. They want to feel understood, valued, and connected to the brands they choose. This can include feelings of trust, happiness, excitement, or even nostalgia. When a company can evoke positive emotions in its customers, it creates a stronger bond and loyalty. 2. Solutions: Beyond just the physical attributes of a product or the transactional nature of a service, customers are ultimately seeking solutions to their problems or needs. Whether it's fulfilling a desire, solving a pain point, or improving their quality of life, customers are drawn to offerings that address their specific challenges and goals. As a customer, this concept means that I'm not just looking for a product or service to fulfill a functional need. I want to feel like my choice matters, that the company understands me, and that they're offering something that genuinely improves my life or situation. For instance, when choosing a smartphone, I don't just want a device with good specs—I want one that integrates seamlessly into my lifestyle, enhances my productivity, and maybe even makes me feel a sense of pride or excitement when using it. Similarly, when selecting a service like a gym membership, I'm not just seeking access to exercise equipment—I'm looking for a solution to my health and fitness goals, along with an environment that motivates and supports me on that journey. 2. Define the term “internal customer.” Why is the concept of internal customer service important to an overall understanding of customer service? Answer: An internal customer is the person who depends on the other people in the company to provide the services and products for the external customer. When the person who is connected long term to a company is treated the way an external customer should be, the results are predictably positive. Internal customers usually do not walk away when the service is bad. This is why treating them right is really important to the overall success of the business. 3. Why is an understanding of the “nice” customer of great importance in improving customer service? Have you ever known or been someone like this “nice” customer, who is unhappy but only leaves and never returns rather than voicing concerns to the business? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. A “nice” customer is the customer who never complains, but responds to bad service by taking his or her business elsewhere. Most customers are like the “nice” customer. These customers would actually be more helpful if they were a bit less nice, because then they would provide better feedback. Understanding the "nice" customer is crucial for improving customer service because they often represent a silent majority whose dissatisfaction might go unnoticed until it's too late. Here's why: 1. Silent Dissatisfaction: Nice customers are often hesitant to voice their concerns or complaints directly to the business. They may not want to cause a fuss, feel uncomfortable with confrontation, or simply believe that their feedback won't make a difference. As a result, they silently tolerate poor service or experiences, but their dissatisfaction still impacts their likelihood of returning or recommending the business to others. 2. Lost Opportunities: If businesses only focus on the most vocal or visible complaints, they risk overlooking the issues that are driving away the quiet, nice customers. These customers might not complain, but they will take their business elsewhere if their needs are consistently unmet or if they don't feel valued. This represents a significant loss of revenue and potential for future growth. 3. Brand Reputation: Even though nice customers may not vocalize their dissatisfaction, they still share their experiences with friends, family, and online communities. If their encounters with a business consistently fall short of expectations, they're likely to discourage others from patronizing that business as well. This can damage the brand's reputation over time. As for whether I've known or been someone like this "nice" customer, I think many people can relate to this behavior to some extent. There have been times when I've experienced subpar service or encountered issues with a product, but instead of making a fuss, I've chosen to quietly take my business elsewhere. It's often easier to avoid confrontation and simply find an alternative solution than to engage in a potentially uncomfortable conversation with a business. However, I recognize that this behavior doesn't help the business improve, and it's better to provide constructive feedback when possible. 4. What are the “two simplest principles” of customer service? What importance does listening play in the use of those principles? Have you ever seen them violated? Answer: The two simplest principles of customer service are: • Find out what the customer needs. • Do whatever is necessary to satisfy those needs. The "two simplest principles" of customer service often cited are: 1. Treat others how you want to be treated (the Golden Rule): This principle emphasizes empathy and respect in all interactions with customers. It means understanding their needs, addressing their concerns promptly and courteously, and striving to provide a positive experience that you would appreciate as a customer yourself. 2. Under-promise and over-deliver: This principle involves managing customer expectations effectively by promising only what you can realistically deliver, and then striving to exceed those expectations whenever possible. It's about delighting customers by pleasantly surprising them with exceptional service or unexpected perks. Listening plays a crucial role in the application of these principles: • Understanding Customer Needs: Effective listening allows service providers to truly understand what their customers want and need. By actively listening to their concerns, preferences, and feedback, businesses can tailor their services to better meet those needs. • Managing Expectations: Listening helps in gauging customer expectations accurately. By paying attention to what customers are asking for or expecting, businesses can ensure they make promises they can keep and avoid disappointing customers by overpromising and underdelivering. • Resolving Issues: Listening attentively to customer complaints or concerns is essential for resolving issues effectively. When customers feel heard and understood, it can go a long way in diffusing tensions and building trust, even if the resolution isn't immediate. Violations of these principles are unfortunately not uncommon. For example: • Overpromising and Under-delivering: Businesses may sometimes promise more than they can realistically deliver in an attempt to win over customers or meet sales targets. This can lead to disappointment and dissatisfaction when customers realize their expectations haven't been met. • Lack of Empathy: Service providers who fail to empathize with their customers may come across as indifferent or uninterested in their needs. This can result in strained relationships and a lack of trust between the business and its customers. • Ignoring Feedback: Businesses that don't actively listen to customer feedback, whether it's through surveys, reviews, or direct communication, miss out on valuable insights for improvement. This can lead to stagnation or decline in customer satisfaction and loyalty over time. By listening carefully to the customer’s stated needs, one might discover unspoken needs. In some cases, the customer does not have a thorough understanding of what his or her own needs are. The task in that case becomes one of probing and asking a series of questions to find out what is behind the surface statements. Students’ answers to the last part of the question will vary. 5. Explain the importance of forming a bond with the customer. How does one go about establishing such a bond? Answer: Few factors will create more impact on overall and repeat sales than bonding with the customer. If one forms meaningful relationships with customers, they are much more likely to return and buy again. This practice is also known as relationship selling. When one has established a relationship with a customer, service is usually perceived more positively. Four ways of establishing a bond with the customer are: • Understand the customer’s real needs. • If the customer is another business, learn about that business. • Provide exceptional service. • Avoid taking the special relationship for granted. 6. What are the four steps in giving the customer bad news? Explain each step. Answer: The four rules for giving a customer bad news are: • Use a polite tone of voice—make it a point to check on this. For many people, vocal tone is mostly unconscious, unless they try specifically to take notice of it. • Don’t spend too much time and energy on apologies—apologizing is fine, but most customers want reasons and action. • Deal with why the problem exists—if the employee doesn’t know, he or she should let the customer know that he or she will find out, then do it. If the problem’s cause is impossible to discover, the employee should go to the next step. • Talk about what can be done to solve the problem—if possible, this includes alternatives and suggestions from which the customer can choose. When only one possible course of action is available, sell the customer on why that action is the best. 7. What are some steps one can take to build the customer’s self-esteem? Which step, in your opinion, is the most important? Explain. Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Some steps that can be taken to build the customer’s self-esteem are: • Put the customer at ease. • Put oneself in the customer’s place. • Make the customer feel understood. • Make the customer feel important. • Praise the customer appropriately. Building a customer's self-esteem is essential for fostering positive relationships and creating loyal patrons. Here are some steps that can be taken to achieve this: 1. Active Listening: Take the time to truly listen to your customers. Pay attention to their concerns, preferences, and needs without interrupting or dismissing them. Show empathy and understanding, making them feel valued and respected. 2. Provide Personalized Attention: Treat each customer as an individual with unique preferences and needs. Tailor your interactions and recommendations to their specific circumstances, making them feel seen and understood. 3. Offer Sincere Compliments and Recognition: Acknowledge and appreciate your customers for their loyalty, patronage, or positive qualities. Sincere compliments and recognition can boost their self-esteem and make them feel good about themselves. 4. Empowerment through Knowledge: Provide customers with information and resources that empower them to make informed decisions and take control of their situations. Knowledge is empowering and can help customers feel confident in their choices. 5. Celebrate Achievements and Milestones: Acknowledge and celebrate your customers' achievements and milestones, whether they're personal or professional. This could be as simple as sending a congratulatory message or offering a special discount or reward. 6. Create a Positive Environment: Foster a welcoming and supportive environment in your business or online community where customers feel comfortable expressing themselves and interacting with others. Positivity breeds positivity and can enhance customers' self-esteem. 7. Follow Up and Follow Through: Demonstrate your commitment to your customers by following up on their experiences and ensuring that any issues or concerns are addressed promptly and effectively. This shows that you value their feedback and are dedicated to their satisfaction. In my opinion, the most important step is active listening. When you truly listen to your customers, you show them that their thoughts, feelings, and opinions matter. This validation can have a significant impact on their self-esteem, as it communicates that they are valued and respected as individuals. Additionally, active listening allows you to better understand your customers' needs and preferences, enabling you to tailor your interactions and offerings in a way that enhances their self-esteem and overall satisfaction. 8. What is meant by “going the extra mile”? Provide an example from your life of either serving customers or being a customer. How did your experience affect you? Was there ever a time when someone didn’t go the extra mile? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. When a company gives customers small “extras” as a way of showing appreciation, it is called “going the extra mile”—and it nearly always pays for itself "Going the extra mile" means providing service or assistance that goes beyond what is typically expected or required. It involves making an additional effort to ensure the satisfaction of the customer or the successful completion of a task. An example from my life as a customer occurred when I was planning a trip with a group of friends. We had booked accommodations at a small bed and breakfast in a remote area. However, on the day of our arrival, we encountered unexpected transportation delays and ended up arriving much later than anticipated, well past the usual check-in hours. Despite the late hour, the owner of the bed and breakfast went the extra mile to accommodate us. Not only did they wait up for our arrival, but they also prepared a late dinner for us and ensured that our rooms were ready and comfortable. Additionally, they provided recommendations for nearby attractions and activities to make the most of our stay, even offering to arrange transportation for us. This experience had a significant impact on me and my friends. We felt genuinely cared for and appreciated the effort the owner had made to accommodate us despite the inconvenience. It turned what could have been a stressful situation into a memorable and enjoyable experience, enhancing our overall impression of the bed and breakfast and ensuring that we would recommend it to others in the future. Conversely, there have been times when someone did not go the extra mile, and the experience was disappointing. For example, I once encountered a situation where I had a technical issue with a product I had purchased, and the customer service representative I contacted was unhelpful and indifferent to my concerns. Instead of making an effort to resolve the issue or offer alternative solutions, they simply reiterated company policies and procedures, leaving me feeling frustrated and dissatisfied with the service I received. This lack of initiative and empathy contrasted starkly with the positive experiences I had had with businesses that went above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. Critical Thinking Questions 9. Try to recall if you can identify a businessperson who was able to establish a bond with you or one of your family members. How was this accomplished? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. The businessperson would have tried to understand one’s real needs, learn about the business if one was another business, provided exceptional service, or avoided taking the special relationship for granted. One businessperson who was able to establish a strong bond with me and my family was the owner of a local bakery in our neighborhood. This individual went above and beyond to create a sense of community and personal connection with their customers. Here's how they accomplished this: 1. Personalized Service: The bakery owner took the time to get to know their customers on a personal level. They remembered our names, our favorite treats, and even asked about our families and interests whenever we visited. This personalized attention made us feel valued and appreciated as customers. 2. Consistent Quality: The bakery consistently delivered high-quality products that were fresh, delicious, and made with care. Whether it was a loaf of bread, a batch of cookies, or a special cake for a celebration, we could always count on the bakery to exceed our expectations. 3. Community Engagement: The bakery actively participated in community events and initiatives, fostering a sense of belonging and camaraderie among residents. They sponsored local sports teams, donated baked goods to fundraisers, and hosted special events like holiday cookie decorating workshops and birthday parties for children. 4. Warm and Welcoming Atmosphere: The bakery had a cozy and inviting atmosphere that made customers feel right at home. The smell of freshly baked goods greeted you as soon as you walked through the door, and the friendly staff always greeted you with a smile and warm welcome. 5. Responsive to Feedback: The bakery owner was receptive to feedback from customers and continuously sought ways to improve their offerings and service. They actively solicited suggestions for new products or flavors and took customer concerns seriously, addressing them promptly and professionally. Overall, it was the combination of personalized service, consistent quality, community engagement, and warm atmosphere that allowed the bakery owner to establish a bond with me and my family. Their genuine care and commitment to their customers made us loyal patrons for many years, and we always looked forward to our visits to the bakery. 10. Have you ever been the victim of a company’s poor customer service policy, as either an external or internal customer? What specifically occurred? How did this treatment make you feel? What would you have changed in that situation if you had the power to do so? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. They would have had different experiences with customer service at different times in their lives. While discussing different issues, they could focus on the best ways to maintain customer relationship and service. Yes, I've experienced poor customer service from a company as an external customer. It was when I had an issue with a product I purchased online, and the company's return and exchange policy made it difficult for me to resolve the issue satisfactorily. Specifically, I had bought a pair of shoes that didn't fit properly, and I wanted to exchange them for a different size. However, when I contacted the company's customer service, I was informed that exchanges were only allowed within a narrow window of time after purchase, and I had missed that window by a few days. Additionally, the return shipping process was cumbersome and required me to cover the cost of shipping, which was quite expensive. This treatment made me feel frustrated and dissatisfied as a customer. It seemed unfair that I couldn't exchange the shoes for the correct size simply because I missed the arbitrary deadline, especially considering that the shoes were still in brand new condition. The lack of flexibility and empathy from the company's customer service representatives left a negative impression on me, and I was unlikely to purchase from them again in the future. If I had the power to change the situation, I would have implemented a more customer-friendly return and exchange policy that allowed for greater flexibility and accommodation of individual circumstances. This could include extending the return/exchange window, providing free return shipping, or offering alternative solutions such as store credit or refunds for unused items. Additionally, I would ensure that customer service representatives were trained to handle inquiries and complaints with empathy, understanding, and a willingness to find mutually beneficial resolutions. This would help to retain customer loyalty and enhance the company's reputation for excellent customer service. Case Studies Case Study 13.1: Disaster in Aisle Three Mrs. Raye’s overloaded shopping cart hits and crashes a display of bottled fruit juices at the health food store where Carmine DeLuccio worked. Upset, she blames the overloading on the small carts and the badly positioned display. Carmine, in the absence of his boss Ann Camilla and the assistant manager, proceeds to handle the situation with the quote, “The customer is always right.” Questions 1. What should Carmine say to Mrs. Raye? Why? Suggested Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Carmine could try to calm down Mrs. Raye while simultaneously arranging for someone to clean up the mess. He should then listen to what Mrs. Raye has to say and carefully consider her view on the cause of the accident. He could assure her that he would speak to his supervisors about the issue of the small size of the carts and ensure that it would be taken care of. Carmine has adopted these methods to calm down the customer due to the belief that an angry or unhappy customer could mean a loss of future business. Carmine should approach Mrs. Raye with empathy and understanding while also taking responsibility for the situation. He could start by apologizing for the accident and expressing concern for any inconvenience or frustration it may have caused her. Next, Carmine should assure Mrs. Raye that he will do everything in his power to rectify the situation. This might involve cleaning up the spilled juices, assisting her with selecting replacement items if necessary, and addressing any safety concerns caused by the overloaded shopping cart or poorly positioned display. While it's important to acknowledge Mrs. Raye's concerns and validate her feelings, Carmine should also gently explain that while the small carts and display positioning may have contributed to the accident, ultimately, it's everyone's responsibility to navigate the store safely and considerately. However, he should refrain from directly blaming Mrs. Raye for the incident, as this could escalate the situation further. By demonstrating genuine concern, taking proactive steps to address the issue, and maintaining a respectful and professional demeanor, Carmine can help diffuse the tension and leave Mrs. Raye feeling valued and satisfied with how the situation was handled. 2. What should he do, and in what order? Suggested Answer: Students’ answers will vary. After having spoken to Mrs. Raye, Carmine can assess the damage and arrange a telephonic conference with his supervisors and enquire whether any damages should be claimed, and resolve the issue in such a manner that Mrs. Raye is adequately satisfied and does not leave angry. Carmine should handle the situation with empathy, professionalism, and a focus on resolving the issue promptly and satisfactorily. Here's a suggested course of action in order: 1. Assess the Situation: Approach Mrs. Raye calmly and assess the extent of the damage caused by the accident. Ensure that there are no safety hazards present and that any spilled juices are promptly cleaned up to prevent slips or falls. 2. Listen to Mrs. Raye: Allow Mrs. Raye to express her concerns and frustrations without interruption. Show empathy and understanding for her experience and acknowledge her feelings of upset caused by the incident. 3. Apologize: Offer a sincere apology to Mrs. Raye for the inconvenience and distress caused by the accident. Take responsibility on behalf of the store for the incident and assure her that you will do everything possible to address the situation. 4. Address Safety Concerns: If Mrs. Raye raises any safety concerns related to the small shopping carts or the positioning of displays, assure her that you will pass on her feedback to the appropriate management team for consideration and action. 5. Offer Assistance: Offer practical assistance to Mrs. Raye to resolve the immediate issue caused by the accident. This may involve helping her select replacement items for any damaged products, providing additional assistance with her shopping, or offering a discount or compensation as a gesture of goodwill. 6. Resolve the Issue: Take proactive steps to rectify the situation, such as cleaning up the spill, organizing the display, and ensuring that Mrs. Raye's shopping experience is as smooth and pleasant as possible from that point forward. 7. Follow Up: After addressing the immediate concerns, follow up with Mrs. Raye to ensure that she is satisfied with how the situation was handled. Thank her for her patience and understanding, and reiterate the store's commitment to providing excellent customer service. By following these steps, Carmine can effectively manage the situation, address Mrs. Raye's concerns, and uphold the store's reputation for exceptional customer service, even in the absence of his superiors. 3. What should Carmine say to the other customers who ask questions such as “What happened over there, anyway?” Suggested Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Carmine should tell the customers that it was an accident, reassure them that it was being taken care of, and tell them that they could continue with their shopping. Carmine should address the other customers' inquiries with transparency and professionalism while also respecting Mrs. Raye's privacy and dignity. Here's how he could handle the situation: 1. Provide a Brief Explanation: Carmine can briefly explain the situation to the other customers who inquire, stating something like, "There was a minor accident involving a shopping cart and a display of bottled juices. We're working to clean it up and ensure everyone's safety." 2. Assure Safety and Apologize for Any Inconvenience: Carmine should reassure the other customers that the situation is under control and that steps are being taken to address it promptly. He can apologize for any inconvenience caused by the incident. 3. Respect Mrs. Raye's Privacy: While providing a general explanation of the situation, Carmine should avoid disclosing Mrs. Raye's identity or placing blame on her. He should maintain confidentiality and handle the matter discreetly to avoid further embarrassment or discomfort for Mrs. Raye. 4. Offer Assistance: If any of the other customers express concern or offer to help with the cleanup efforts, Carmine can thank them for their willingness to assist but assure them that the situation is being managed by store staff. 5. Redirect Attention: After providing a brief explanation and addressing any immediate concerns, Carmine can gently redirect the conversation to focus on the positive aspects of the shopping experience, such as highlighting special promotions or new products in the store. By handling the inquiries from other customers with transparency, professionalism, and sensitivity, Carmine can help diffuse any potential tension or curiosity surrounding the incident while maintaining a positive shopping atmosphere for everyone involved. Case Study 13.2: International Business Calling Dana Smith, the manager at the U.S office of the tourism company, is frustrated at the issue of several tourists cutting short their vacation in China due to illness. When Wei Ting, her agent in Singapore, calls in with a client on line for reimbursement for a denied visa, Dana does not wait to hear the issue but snaps at Wei Ting for not being able to handle such “complaining customers”. This angers the listening customer and embarrasses Wei Ting. Dana blames Wei Ting for not warning her about the customer being on line. Questions 1. Does this situation have more to do with external customer relations, with internal customer relations, or both? Explain. Suggested Answer: Students’ answers may vary. This situation deals with both the internal customer, Wei Ting (the company’s agent in Singapore), as well as the external customer, the disgruntled client. Both are equally important to the firm. This situation primarily involves internal customer relations, but it also indirectly affects external customer relations. 1. Internal Customer Relations: The interaction between Dana and Wei Ting is a clear example of internal customer relations. Wei Ting is an internal customer of Dana, as she relies on him to effectively manage client issues and communicate with her about important matters. Dana's frustration and snap reaction towards Wei Ting demonstrate a breakdown in internal communication and collaboration, which can negatively impact team morale and productivity. 2. External Customer Relations: While the immediate issue revolves around Dana's reaction to Wei Ting, the consequences of her behavior extend to external customer relations. By snapping at Wei Ting in front of a client, Dana not only embarrasses Wei Ting but also creates a poor impression on the client. This can damage the company's reputation and erode trust with both current and potential customers. Additionally, Dana's frustration with tourists falling ill during their vacations in China may also indicate broader challenges in managing customer experiences and satisfaction. Overall, while the immediate conflict is internal between Dana and Wei Ting, the repercussions of Dana's behavior have implications for both internal team dynamics and external customer relationships. 2. What should Dana do to resolve the situation on all fronts? What should Wei Ting do to keep the client happy and develop a better working relationship with Dana? Suggested Answer: Student answers will vary. Dana should, first of all, calm down and apologize to and empathize with the client on the visa issue. She should then let the customer vent his frustration while remaining calm and apologizing whenever necessary. She should also consider her customer’s complaints carefully and focus on strategies to keep the customer satisfied, while at the same time, making sure that her company does not get jeopardized. Wei Ting should also apologize to the client for the situation, mention that he was not wrong in asking for a refund, and should not take Dana’s reaction personally. Ting should hand over the call to Dana who can take the conversation forward, ask for time to help the client resolve the issue, and reassure the client of a satisfactory solution. Wei Ting can change his approach while dealing with Dana. He can think of all possible alternatives for an issue and then consult Dana for the best possible alternative. In this manner, Dana would also feel that she has support. He should also keep in mind that he should not involve the customer in the initial stages of solving issues. To resolve the situation and address the concerns on all fronts, Dana and Wei Ting should take the following actions: Dana's Actions: 1. Apologize to Wei Ting: Dana should apologize to Wei Ting for snapping at him in front of the client. Acknowledging her mistake and taking responsibility for her actions is the first step towards rebuilding trust and repairing their working relationship. 2. Listen to Wei Ting: Dana should take the time to listen to Wei Ting's perspective and the reasons behind the client's call. Understanding the challenges faced by Wei Ting and the client can help Dana empathize with their situation and find a constructive solution. 3. Address the Immediate Issue: Dana should address the client's concern regarding the denied visa reimbursement promptly and professionally. She should apologize to the client for any inconvenience caused and work with Wei Ting to resolve the issue to the client's satisfaction. 4. Provide Support and Guidance: Instead of blaming Wei Ting for the situation, Dana should offer support and guidance to help him handle similar issues in the future. This could include providing additional training or resources to handle customer complaints effectively. 5. Implement Better Communication Practices: Dana should establish clear communication protocols with Wei Ting and other team members to ensure that important information, such as client calls, is communicated in a timely and efficient manner. This can help prevent misunderstandings and improve teamwork within the organization. Wei Ting's Actions: 1. Remain Professional: Despite Dana's outburst, Wei Ting should remain professional and composed when interacting with both Dana and the client. Avoiding escalation and maintaining a calm demeanor can help diffuse tension and focus on resolving the client's issue. 2. Empathize with the Client: Wei Ting should empathize with the client's situation and demonstrate understanding and concern for their frustrations regarding the denied visa reimbursement. Assure the client that their concerns are being taken seriously and that efforts are being made to find a satisfactory resolution. 3. Communicate Effectively with Dana: Wei Ting should communicate openly and transparently with Dana about the client's call and the reasons behind it. Providing Dana with relevant information and updates can help keep her informed and prevent misunderstandings in the future. 4. Seek Feedback and Guidance: If unsure about how to handle a particular client issue or navigate challenges with Dana, Wei Ting should seek feedback and guidance from Dana or other colleagues. Learning from past experiences and incorporating feedback can help improve his performance and strengthen his working relationship with Dana. By taking these actions, Dana and Wei Ting can work together to resolve the immediate issue with the client and rebuild trust and collaboration within the team. Effective communication, empathy, and a commitment to professionalism are essential for achieving a positive outcome in this situation. 3. Explain how this company could encourage complaints in the future to avoid such situations. What types of complaints and solutions would you anticipate management receiving in this company? Suggested Answer: Students’ answers will vary. The company should make complaining easy for the customers, keeping in mind that a complaint is always an opportunity for the organization to improve and grow, and is crucial to keeping customers happy and retaining them as loyal customers. Complaints should be encouraged, and various methods of rewarding customer complaints can be used. Most importantly, the company should make sure to correct customer complaints. The company can also follow up with customers after resolution of the issue to see if the issue has been resolved to their satisfaction. The company may receive complaints on various issues, like issues with itinerary, late arrivals, poor bus service, cancellations, salespeople who aren’t amiable, etc. The company can arrive at the best solution for each issue, taking individual factors into account. To encourage complaints in the future and prevent similar situations from occurring, the company could implement several strategies: 1. Create a Supportive Environment: Foster a culture where employees feel comfortable raising concerns and providing feedback without fear of retribution. Encourage open communication channels and assure employees that their input is valued and will be taken seriously. 2. Provide Training and Resources: Offer training sessions or workshops on effective communication and conflict resolution skills for employees, especially those who interact directly with customers. Equip them with the tools and knowledge needed to handle complaints professionally and empathetically. 3. Establish a Formal Complaints Process: Implement a formalized complaints process where customers can easily submit their grievances and receive timely responses. Ensure that there are multiple channels available for lodging complaints, such as phone, email, or an online portal. 4. Incentivize Feedback: Offer incentives or rewards for customers who provide feedback or submit complaints, such as discounts on future purchases or entry into prize draws. This can encourage more customers to share their experiences and concerns with the company. 5. Monitor and Analyze Complaint Data: Regularly monitor and analyze complaint data to identify trends, common issues, and areas for improvement. Use this information to proactively address underlying problems and prevent similar issues from recurring in the future. Anticipated complaints and potential solutions in this tourism company might include: 1. Customer Service Issues: Complaints related to poor customer service, such as rude or unhelpful staff, long wait times, or unresponsive communication channels. Solutions could include additional training for employees, hiring more staff to reduce wait times, and implementing technology to improve communication efficiency. 2. Quality of Services: Complaints about the quality of services provided, such as subpar accommodations, transportation delays, or misleading tour descriptions. Solutions may involve conducting quality assurance checks, partnering with reputable vendors, and offering refunds or compensation for dissatisfied customers. 3. Health and Safety Concerns: Complaints regarding health and safety issues during tours, such as food poisoning, accidents, or inadequate medical assistance. Solutions could include implementing stricter safety protocols, providing comprehensive health and safety training for staff, and ensuring access to emergency medical services at all tour destinations. By encouraging complaints and actively addressing customer concerns, the company can demonstrate its commitment to customer satisfaction and continuously improve its services to meet and exceed customer expectations. CHAPTER 14 Human Relations in a World of Diversity Review Questions 1. What are the three components of an attitude? Describe the three components of a prejudiced attitude. Answer: All attitudes have three parts—what people think, feel, and do. The three components of a prejudiced attitude are: • Stereotypes—one’s thoughts or beliefs about specific groups of people. • Prejudice—how one feels as a result of his or her stereotypes. • Discrimination—one’s behavior, or what one does (or intends to do, or is inclined to do) as a result of his or her stereotypes and prejudice. 2. What individuals and groups can you think of who are likely targets of prejudice and discrimination? Do you fit into any of these groups that are likely targets? Have you ever found yourself a target of prejudice or discrimination as a member of this group? Explain. Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Individuals and groups who belong to minority or ethnic groups, women, homosexuals, the elderly, disabled, over-weight people region are more likely to face prejudice. Many individuals and groups are unfortunately targets of prejudice and discrimination due to various factors such as race, ethnicity, religion, gender, sexual orientation, disability, socioeconomic status, and age. Some examples include: 1. Racial and Ethnic Minorities: People of color, including Black, Indigenous, and Hispanic individuals, often face discrimination based on their race or ethnicity. 2. Religious Minorities: Individuals belonging to religious minority groups, such as Muslims, Jews, Sikhs, and Hindus, may experience prejudice and discrimination due to their faith. 3. LGBTQ+ Community: Lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer, and other gender and sexual minority individuals often face discrimination based on their sexual orientation or gender identity. 4. Women: Women frequently experience discrimination based on gender, including in the workplace, education, and social settings. 5. People with Disabilities: Individuals with physical, mental, or developmental disabilities may encounter discrimination in various aspects of life, including employment, accessibility, and social inclusion. 6. Immigrants and Refugees: Immigrants, asylum seekers, and refugees may face prejudice and discrimination due to their nationality, immigration status, or cultural background. 7. Older Adults: Older adults can be targets of ageism, experiencing discrimination or stereotypes based on their age. I understand the importance of empathy and awareness of discrimination and prejudice in society. While I don't fit into any of these groups personally, I recognize the significance of supporting and advocating for those who do face discrimination and prejudice. It's essential to stand in solidarity with marginalized communities and work towards creating a more inclusive and equitable society for all. 3. Discuss some of the sources of prejudice. Within these sources, can you think of a particular prejudice that you have and how it arose? Explain your personal example. Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Some sources of prejudice are: • Social Causes—one theory is that people form prejudices to try to raise their own self-esteem, such as when climbing the career or social ladder. Another social theory is that prejudice helps people define themselves and feel socially accepted. A final social theory of prejudice looks at institutional support systems, or the way organizations and society itself unintentionally create institutional racism, sexism, or exclusionary policies. • Cognitive Causes—cognitive causes have to do with thinking and reasoning processes. Some psychologists believe that prejudice originates with a process called cognitive categorization, in which the mind quickly sorts information into categories to function efficiently. • Emotional Causes—ethnocentrism is the cause of a great deal of prejudice that people experience. Human beings tend to see their own ethnic groups as the most normal, and they believe their way of seeing and doing things is the right way. Prejudice can stem from various sources, including: 1. Socialization: Prejudice can be learned through socialization processes, such as upbringing, family influences, peer interactions, and cultural norms. Individuals may internalize biases and stereotypes from their social environment without critically examining them. 2. Media and Stereotypes: Media representations, including television, movies, news media, and social media, can perpetuate stereotypes and reinforce prejudiced attitudes towards certain groups. Biased portrayals in the media can shape perceptions and contribute to the formation of prejudiced beliefs. 3. Group Dynamics: Prejudice can arise from group dynamics, including ingroup favoritism and outgroup derogation. People may develop prejudices against individuals or groups perceived as different from their own ingroup, leading to discrimination and social exclusion. 4. Cognitive Processes: Cognitive biases, such as categorization, confirmation bias, and attribution errors, can contribute to the formation and reinforcement of prejudice. These biases distort perceptions and lead individuals to make unfair generalizations about entire groups based on limited information or experiences. 5. Socioeconomic Factors: Socioeconomic disparities and power dynamics can fuel prejudice and discrimination. Marginalized groups may be perceived as threatening to the status quo or blamed for societal problems, leading to scapegoating and discrimination. However, I can provide a hypothetical example to illustrate how prejudice can arise: Imagine growing up in a community where negative stereotypes about a certain racial or ethnic group are prevalent. You may hear derogatory comments or jokes about this group from family members, peers, and media sources. Over time, these repeated messages can influence your perceptions and attitudes towards members of that group, leading to the internalization of prejudiced beliefs. For instance, if you repeatedly hear stereotypes about people from a particular racial background being lazy or unintelligent, you may come to unconsciously associate those traits with individuals from that group. This can result in prejudiced attitudes and discriminatory behavior towards members of that racial group, even if you've never had direct personal interactions with them to challenge or contradict those stereotypes. 4. Discuss the negative effects of discrimination in the workplace, both on the individual and on the business organization. Have you seen any discriminatory acts occurring in your workplace? Explain. Answer: Students’ answers will vary. What many employers fail to realize is that by discriminating against employees because of their racial prejudices, these employers are damaging their own productivity (by reducing morale) and not capturing the skills and talents of these employees. This waste of talent is overwhelming. They are also shortchanging their own businesses by not employing (or by underemploying) a large pool of potential employees with a high degree of talent and skills. Discrimination in the workplace can have numerous negative effects on both individuals and the organization as a whole: Negative Effects on Individuals: 1. Emotional and Psychological Impact: Discrimination can lead to feelings of anger, frustration, sadness, and low self-esteem among affected individuals. It can also cause anxiety, depression, and other mental health issues, impacting their overall well-being. 2. Stress and Burnout: Discrimination creates a hostile work environment, increasing stress levels and contributing to burnout. Constantly facing unfair treatment or harassment can take a toll on an individual's physical and mental health, leading to absenteeism and decreased productivity. 3. Career Limitations: Discrimination can hinder an individual's career advancement opportunities, as they may face barriers such as being passed over for promotions, denied training and development opportunities, or being excluded from important projects or networking opportunities. Negative Effects on the Organization: 1. Decreased Employee Morale and Engagement: Discrimination erodes trust and morale within the workplace, leading to disengagement and reduced productivity among employees. When employees feel undervalued or marginalized, they are less likely to be motivated to perform at their best. 2. Legal Risks and Reputational Damage: Discriminatory practices expose organizations to legal risks, including lawsuits, fines, and damage to their reputation. Discrimination lawsuits can be costly in terms of legal fees, settlements, and damage to the company's public image, resulting in financial losses and loss of trust among stakeholders. 3. Loss of Talent and Innovation: Discrimination drives away talented employees who feel unwelcome or unsupported in the workplace. Organizations that fail to create inclusive environments miss out on the diverse perspectives and innovative ideas that come from a diverse workforce, putting them at a competitive disadvantage. However, discrimination can manifest in various forms, including unequal treatment based on race, gender, age, disability, sexual orientation, or other protected characteristics. It's important for organizations to foster a culture of diversity, equity, and inclusion and to actively address and prevent discrimination through policies, training, and accountability measures. 5. Describe steps that can be taken in the workplace to reduce or prevent sexual harassment. Answer: Some steps that can be taken in the workplace to reduce or prevent sexual harassment are: • Write a policy statement—if you are a supervisor or manager, you should have a fairly brief but well-written policy concerning sexual harassment. • Post the policy statement in a public place—this policy should be printed in fairly large print and posted in central locations where all employees can see it. • Talk about the policy—besides this, you should refer to the policy in meetings and memos, so it won’t become just another poster the boss put up. 6. How is institutional racism or institutional sexism different from open racism or sexism? Answer: Institutional racism or sexism may involve prejudices caused by policies in the workplace that are not intentionally set to exclude members of specific groups or to treat them differently, but which have that effect anyway. Open racism or sexism involves knowingly discriminating against the victim. 7. What is meant by the term self-fulfilling prophecy? Think of an example in your life or someone else’s where a self-fulfilling prophecy (either positive or negative) arose. Explain your personal example. Answer: Students’ answers will vary. A self-fulfilling prophecy occurs when a victim believes that prejudice against him or her is deserved and then becomes what the stereotype states. A self-fulfilling prophecy refers to a belief or expectation that influences a person's behavior in a way that ultimately confirms the belief or expectation. In other words, a self-fulfilling prophecy occurs when someone's belief about a situation leads them to act in a manner that brings about the predicted outcome, regardless of whether the belief was initially true or accurate. A personal example of a self-fulfilling prophecy could involve a student who believes they are not good at a particular subject, such as mathematics. Due to this belief, the student may approach their math classes with a negative attitude, avoid studying or seeking help, and perform poorly on assignments and exams. As a result, their grades in math class may indeed be low, thus confirming their belief that they are not good at math. In this example, the student's initial belief that they are not good at math influences their behavior and actions, leading to a self-perpetuating cycle of poor performance and reinforcing the belief. This demonstrates how a self-fulfilling prophecy can have significant effects on an individual's outcomes and experiences. It's worth noting that self-fulfilling prophecies can also occur in positive contexts. For instance, if a person believes they are capable of achieving success in their career, they may approach their work with confidence, motivation, and determination. This positive attitude and behavior can increase their chances of achieving their goals, thus fulfilling the prophecy of success. 8. What are some of the common myths about people with disabilities in the workplace? What is being done to protect employment for this group? Answer: Some common myths about disabled people are that they are unreliable; they can’t do very many jobs, and they will make other employees feel uncomfortable. The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) allows people with disabilities to enjoy most of the benefits that everyone else enjoys. The ADA prohibits discrimination by companies in any of the following areas—employment, public transportation, telecommunication, and other privately owned services to the public (hotels and motels, restaurants and bars, public gathering places). Also, the law requires that benefits and opportunities for people with disabilities must be of the same quality as those offered to everyone else, if possible. Critical Thinking Questions 9. Under what circumstances is it acceptable to treat co-workers or employees differently because of their differences? Should you be blind to differences between co-workers or employees, or recognize them openly? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Companies should have rules to ensure that all employees are treated equally. However, there may be a few circumstances which would require a certain amount of flexibility. For example, considering the social status of women in the family, employers can try to provide them a job that offers satisfying work and a chance for advancement, with enough flexibility to allow for raising a family. In addition, employers are generally required to accommodate employees who express a need to practice religious beliefs at work, but they do have some flexibility in how these accommodations will be made. Treating co-workers or employees differently based on their differences is acceptable only in certain circumstances, such as: 1. Accommodating Diversity: It is acceptable to treat co-workers or employees differently to accommodate their individual needs, preferences, or abilities. For example, providing reasonable accommodations for employees with disabilities or adjusting work schedules to accommodate religious observances. 2. Inclusivity Initiatives: Implementing diversity and inclusion initiatives may involve treating employees differently to promote equity and representation within the workplace. This could include targeted recruitment efforts to diversify the workforce or providing mentorship and development opportunities for underrepresented groups. 3. Performance and Merit-Based Differences: It may be acceptable to treat employees differently based on their performance, skills, and contributions to the organization. Rewarding high performers with bonuses, promotions, or additional responsibilities is a common practice in many workplaces. However, it's important to distinguish between treating employees differently in ways that promote fairness, equity, and inclusion, versus discrimination or bias based on irrelevant factors such as race, gender, age, or other protected characteristics. Discrimination based on these factors is never acceptable and is prohibited by law in many jurisdictions. As for whether you should be blind to differences between co-workers or employees or recognize them openly, it depends on the context: 1. Recognize and Respect Differences: Acknowledging and respecting differences among co-workers or employees can foster a more inclusive and supportive work environment. Embracing diversity can lead to better collaboration, creativity, and problem-solving within teams. 2. Focus on Common Goals and Values: While recognizing differences, it's also important to emphasize shared goals, values, and objectives that unite employees. Emphasizing commonalities can help build cohesion and teamwork while minimizing potential conflicts or misunderstandings. 3. Addressing Bias and Discrimination: Being blind to differences can perpetuate bias and discrimination by ignoring the unique challenges and experiences faced by marginalized or underrepresented groups. Instead, organizations should actively work to address bias and discrimination through education, training, and inclusive policies and practices. Ultimately, the goal should be to create a workplace culture that values diversity, equity, and inclusion while treating all employees with fairness, dignity, and respect. 10. People today talk a lot about “tolerance.” Is there a difference between tolerance and acceptance of differences, whether they are cultural, gender-related, religious, or other? Explain the differences. Answer: Yes, there is a difference between tolerance and acceptance of differences, although the two concepts are related: 1. Tolerance: Tolerance refers to the ability to tolerate or endure differences without necessarily agreeing with or fully embracing them. It involves respecting the rights and beliefs of others, even if they differ from one's own. Tolerance acknowledges diversity and allows individuals to coexist peacefully despite their differences. However, tolerance can imply a level of reluctance or resignation, as it does not necessarily involve embracing or celebrating diversity. 2. Acceptance: Acceptance, on the other hand, goes beyond tolerance and involves embracing and welcoming differences without judgment or prejudice. It entails recognizing and valuing the unique identities, perspectives, and experiences of others, even if they differ from one's own. Acceptance involves openness, understanding, and appreciation for diversity, as well as a willingness to learn from and engage with people of diverse backgrounds. In summary, while tolerance involves acknowledging and respecting differences, acceptance takes it a step further by actively embracing and celebrating diversity. Tolerance may imply a passive coexistence, while acceptance implies a more proactive and inclusive approach to diversity and inclusion. Ultimately, fostering acceptance of differences promotes greater empathy, understanding, and harmony within society. Case Studies Case Study 14.1: It’s None of Your Business A professor with a Ph.D. was interviewing for a research job at a university in California. The interviewer persisted with questions that were not permissible under the prevention of discrimination in the Civil Rights act. The questions probe personal details covering age and marital status to future plans on parenthood. Questions 1. Thinking about the questions, if you were considering hiring someone and wanted to be sure that you were hiring a reliable employee, these are things you might want to know as well. So, why can’t you ask these questions? What is inherently wrong with wanting to know these things about a potential employee—why is it illegal, when not directly related to job tasks? Suggested Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Such a line of questioning by an interviewer is illegal as it is discriminatory against the interviewee and is not required to assess the skills the individual possesses for the job role he or she is being interviewed for. While it might seem logical or relevant to inquire about personal details such as age, marital status, or future plans on parenthood when hiring someone, it is illegal to ask these questions under the prevention of discrimination laws for several reasons: 1. Protected Characteristics: Questions about age, marital status, and plans for parenthood can be indicative of protected characteristics under anti-discrimination laws. For example, in the United States, the Civil Rights Act prohibits discrimination based on age, marital status, and gender (which can be inferred from questions about parenthood). Asking such questions can potentially lead to discrimination against individuals based on these protected characteristics. 2. Irrelevance to Job Performance: Personal details such as age, marital status, and plans for parenthood are generally irrelevant to a person's ability to perform job tasks. Focusing on these aspects during the hiring process can unfairly disadvantage qualified candidates and overlook their skills, qualifications, and experiences relevant to the job. 3. Invasion of Privacy: Inquiring about personal details that are not directly related to job tasks can be seen as an invasion of privacy. Candidates have a right to privacy regarding their personal lives, and asking intrusive questions can create discomfort or pressure for candidates to disclose sensitive information unnecessarily. 4. Risk of Bias and Stereotyping: Asking questions related to protected characteristics can perpetuate bias and stereotypes in the hiring process. For example, making assumptions about a candidate's suitability for a job based on their age, marital status, or plans for parenthood can lead to unfair treatment and discrimination. Overall, while employers may have legitimate concerns about hiring reliable employees, it is essential to focus on factors directly relevant to job performance and to avoid inquiries that may lead to discrimination or privacy violations. Employers can assess candidates' reliability through job-related qualifications, experience, skills, and references without delving into personal details that are not pertinent to the job. 2. Using the skills you have learned in previous chapters and the information you have learned in this chapter, what would you have said to this interviewer during the interview, in order to end these personal questions? Suggested Answer: Students’ answers will vary. One could have probably told the interviewer that the questions he or she was putting forward were too personal and that he or she thought that the questions would not be assessing any of his or her skills required for the job at stake. If faced with personal questions during a job interview that are not permissible under anti-discrimination laws, I would handle the situation professionally and assertively. Here's how I might respond to the interviewer to end these personal questions: "Thank you for the opportunity to interview for this position. While I understand your interest in getting to know me better, I would like to focus our discussion on my qualifications and experiences relevant to the job. I believe that my skills and expertise make me a strong candidate for this role, and I'm eager to discuss how I can contribute to the research team here at the university." By redirecting the conversation back to the qualifications and job-related aspects of the interview, I assertively communicate my boundaries while maintaining a professional demeanor. This approach signals to the interviewer that I am aware of my rights as a candidate and am not willing to engage in discussions that violate anti-discrimination laws. Additionally, by emphasizing my enthusiasm for the position and my ability to contribute to the organization, I keep the focus on my suitability for the job rather than personal details that are irrelevant to the hiring decision. 3. Let’s say the interviewer continued this line of personal questions, even after you said something. The interview ended, and you were not hired. Would you have taken further action? Explain. Suggested Answer: Students’ answers will vary. One can report the incident to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), which is a federal agency established to monitor the laws set in place by the amended Civil Rights Act of 1972. If the interviewer persisted with personal questions that were not permissible under anti-discrimination laws, even after I assertively redirected the conversation, and I ultimately was not hired for the position, I would consider taking further action. Here are steps I might take: 1. Document the Interview: I would document the details of the interview, including the questions asked and any inappropriate or discriminatory behavior exhibited by the interviewer. Keeping a record of the interview can provide evidence if further action is necessary. 2. Consult with Legal Counsel: I would consult with legal counsel or seek advice from an employment law attorney to understand my rights and options. They can provide guidance on whether the interviewer's behavior constitutes discrimination under anti-discrimination laws and advise on potential courses of action. 3. File a Complaint: If I believe that I experienced discrimination during the interview process, I may choose to file a complaint with the appropriate regulatory agency, such as the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) in the United States. The complaint would trigger an investigation into the alleged discrimination and could result in legal action against the employer if warranted. 4. Seek Redress through Legal Channels: Depending on the outcome of the investigation and legal advice, I may pursue legal action against the employer for discrimination. This could involve filing a lawsuit seeking damages for lost wages, emotional distress, or other remedies available under anti-discrimination laws. 5. Raise Awareness: I might also consider raising awareness about the issue of discrimination in the hiring process by sharing my experience publicly or through advocacy organizations dedicated to promoting workplace equality and fairness. Ultimately, the decision to take further action would depend on the severity of the discrimination, the advice of legal counsel, and my personal preferences and circumstances. However, it's essential to address discriminatory behavior in the workplace to protect the rights of individuals and promote a culture of fairness and equality. Case Study 14.2: Two Against One Julia Sandoval and Kathy O’Donnell, two employees in a small software design company were hateful of the department secretary, Miranda Kirkpatrick, which they claim was due to Miranda’s boastfulness. Elena Aguilar-Trujillo, who managed her eight employees as the department director, observes that the resentment can be traced to the fact that Miranda, with a successful businessman husband, was financially better off than her two complaining employees. She decides to discuss the issue with the two. Questions 1. What type of prejudice is being illustrated here? What is it based on? Suggested Answer: The prejudice that is being illustrated here is economic prejudice. It is based on prejudice and discrimination toward people who are poorer or wealthier than one is. The type of prejudice being illustrated here is likely socioeconomic prejudice, which is based on differences in financial status or socioeconomic class. Julia Sandoval and Kathy O'Donnell resent Miranda Kirkpatrick because they perceive her as boastful and financially better off due to her successful businessman husband. Their animosity towards Miranda seems to stem from feelings of envy or resentment towards her perceived socioeconomic privilege. Elena Aguilar-Trujillo, the department director, observes that the resentment towards Miranda can be traced to the fact that she is financially better off than Julia and Kathy. This suggests that the prejudice is based on socioeconomic differences, where Julia and Kathy feel inferior or disadvantaged compared to Miranda due to her higher socioeconomic status. 2. If Elena did decide to fire Miranda in order to keep the peace within the department, what legal recourse would Miranda have, if any? Explain. Suggested Answer: Miranda can report the incident to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), which is a federal agency established to monitor the laws set in place by the amended Civil Rights Act of 1972. If Elena decided to fire Miranda based on the resentment and complaints from Julia Sandoval and Kathy O'Donnell, Miranda may have legal recourse under employment discrimination laws, specifically laws that protect against discrimination based on marital status or socioeconomic status. Here's how Miranda's situation might align with legal protections: 1. Marital Status Discrimination: If Miranda's termination was motivated by resentment towards her successful businessman husband, it could be considered marital status discrimination. Employment discrimination laws in many jurisdictions prohibit adverse employment actions, such as termination, based on an employee's marital status or the status of their spouse. 2. Socioeconomic Discrimination: Miranda's termination due to her perceived financial status, as indicated by her husband's success, could also constitute socioeconomic discrimination. Discrimination based on an employee's socioeconomic status, wealth, or financial situation is prohibited under employment discrimination laws in many jurisdictions. If Miranda believes she was terminated unlawfully based on either of these protected characteristics, she may have legal recourse to challenge her termination. She could file a complaint with the appropriate regulatory agency, such as the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) in the United States, alleging discrimination. The agency would then investigate the complaint and determine whether there is evidence of unlawful discrimination. If the agency finds merit in Miranda's complaint, she may be entitled to remedies such as reinstatement, back pay, compensatory damages for emotional distress, and attorney's fees. Additionally, Miranda could pursue a lawsuit against her employer for wrongful termination based on discrimination, seeking further damages and relief through the courts. It's important for employers to adhere to anti-discrimination laws and make employment decisions based on job-related factors rather than personal characteristics or biases. Discriminatory terminations not only violate employees' rights but can also result in legal consequences and damage to the employer's reputation. 3. Let’s say you have been called in as a mediator to settle this interdepartmental conflict. What steps will you take? What will these steps be based on? Suggested Answer: Students’ answers will vary. A mediator can discuss that the key ingredient to understand and appreciate members of other groups is contact and communication, as proximity (physical closeness) and exposure to other people generally increase the chance that they will come to like each other. It will also reduce any tendency to stereotype groups of people. These steps can be based on conflict analysis. As a mediator called in to settle the interdepartmental conflict between Miranda Kirkpatrick, Julia Sandoval, and Kathy O'Donnell, I would take the following steps: 1. Listen to Each Party: I would start by listening to each party involved in the conflict. This would involve giving them the opportunity to express their perspectives, concerns, and feelings about the situation without interruption. Active listening is crucial to understanding the underlying issues and emotions driving the conflict. 2. Identify Underlying Concerns: I would work to identify the underlying concerns and interests of each party. This may involve asking clarifying questions to uncover the root causes of the conflict and any unmet needs or expectations. Understanding the underlying concerns can help identify common ground and potential solutions. 3. Facilitate Communication: I would facilitate open and constructive communication between the parties, encouraging them to express themselves respectfully and listen to each other's perspectives. This may involve setting ground rules for communication, such as using "I" statements, refraining from interrupting, and focusing on problem-solving rather than blame. 4. Generate Options for Resolution: I would help the parties brainstorm and generate potential options for resolving the conflict. This could involve exploring compromises, creative solutions, or alternative approaches that address the underlying concerns of all parties involved. Encouraging flexibility and open-mindedness can help broaden the range of possible solutions. 5. Negotiate Agreement: Once options for resolution have been identified, I would facilitate negotiation between the parties to reach a mutually acceptable agreement. This may involve exploring trade-offs, clarifying expectations, and finding common ground. It's important to ensure that the agreement is fair, balanced, and sustainable for all parties involved. 6. Document Agreement: Once an agreement has been reached, I would document the terms of the agreement in writing, ensuring that all parties understand and agree to the terms. This helps provide clarity and accountability moving forward and serves as a reference point in case of future disputes. These steps would be based on principles of conflict resolution and mediation, including active listening, communication skills, empathy, impartiality, and a focus on collaborative problem-solving. By guiding the parties through a structured mediation process, I would aim to help them reach a mutually satisfactory resolution to the conflict. Solution Manual for Human Relations: Strategies for Success Lowell Lamberton, Leslie Minor-Evans 9780073524689
