Preview Extract
This document contains Chapters 1 to 2 CHAPTER 1 Human Relations: A Background Review Questions In your own words, write a one• or two-sentence definition of human relations as you would have defined it before reading this chapter. Then, assuming your definition has changed a bit, write a new one. Answer: Human relations is the maintenance of proper relationships among other people or employees within any organization. It is the skill or ability to work effectively through and with other people, which includes a desire to understand others needs, weaknesses, talents and abilities. Students might come up with various definitions. Before reading the chapter, I might have defined human relations as the interactions and connections between individuals in various social settings. However, after reading the chapter, my understanding has deepened to see human relations as the study of how people interact, communicate, and behave within groups, organizations, and societies, encompassing elements such as psychology, sociology, and communication. Explain the importance of Elton Mayo and his work in the Hawthorne studies to the history of human relations. Answer: Two important discoveries came from Elton Mayo’s Hawthorne studies. First, Mayo showed that the workers at Hawthorne performed better because someone was paying attention to them. This attention was more than they had been accustomed to receiving at work, and they responded with extra motivation. Second, Mayo found that the relationships that had formed naturally in the workplace made up what he called the informal organization. On days when a worker would not be as motivated as usual, the expectations of the group would make up the difference, and productivity would remain high. How can the development of human relations skills help you on the job as a manager? As an entrepreneur? As an employee? Answer: Developing human relations skills can greatly benefit individuals in various professional roles: As a manager: Human relations skills are essential for effective leadership and team management. Managers with strong human relations skills can build rapport with their team members, communicate effectively, resolve conflicts, and motivate employees to achieve organizational goals. They can create a positive work environment, foster collaboration, and build trust, which ultimately leads to higher employee morale, productivity, and retention. As an entrepreneur: Human relations skills are crucial for entrepreneurs in building and maintaining relationships with customers, suppliers, investors, and employees. Entrepreneurs who excel in human relations can effectively network, negotiate deals, understand customer needs, and build a loyal customer base. Additionally, they can inspire and lead their team through the challenges of starting and growing a business, fostering a culture of innovation, adaptability, and teamwork. As an employee: Human relations skills are valuable for employees at all levels within an organization. Employees with strong human relations skills can communicate effectively with colleagues, collaborate on projects, and contribute to a positive work culture. They can resolve conflicts constructively, build strong professional relationships, and work well in teams. These skills can enhance job satisfaction, career advancement opportunities, and overall success in the workplace. Explain the role of W. Edwards Deming in the further development of human relations concepts during the past two decades. Answer: W. Edwards Deming introduced Total Quality Management in the United States. This important school of thought held that the process of whatever happens in an organization is more important than the product. Doing away with targets, “zero defects” programs, and slogans, the TQM people concentrated on the process—which inevitably includes people and relationships. By the late 1980s, Total Quality Management had changed industry both in America and abroad. List three reasons why human relations issues are more important today than ever before. Answer: Human relations issues are increasingly important today due to several factors: 1. Globalization: With the interconnectedness of the global economy, businesses and organizations are dealing with diverse workforces comprising individuals from different cultures, backgrounds, and perspectives. Managing such diversity requires strong human relations skills to foster understanding, cooperation, and effective communication among employees and across borders. 2. Technological advancements: The rapid pace of technological change has transformed the way people communicate and interact, both within and outside the workplace. While technology has facilitated remote work and virtual collaboration, it has also created new challenges such as digital communication overload, cyberbullying, and social isolation. Addressing these challenges requires human relations skills to navigate digital interactions, maintain meaningful connections, and foster a healthy work-life balance. 3. Shift towards knowledge-based economies: In today's knowledge-based economies, organizations rely heavily on the expertise, creativity, and collaboration of their employees to drive innovation and competitive advantage. Human relations issues such as employee engagement, talent retention, and knowledge sharing are therefore critical for organizational success. Effective human relations strategies can help organizations attract, develop, and retain top talent, creating a culture of continuous learning, growth, and innovation. Why is self-esteem important to the development of human relation skills? Answer: The study of human relations has two goals: personal development and growth, and achievement of an organization’s objectives. Self-esteem, which is one’s feeling of confidence and worth as a person, is one of the many areas of emphasis that takes both of those goals into consideration. Psychological research has shown that lower self-esteem is related to a variety of mental health issues, including alcoholism, anxiety, and depression—all of which cause problems on the job. Higher self-esteem, on the other hand, improves attitudes, job morale, and overall quality of life. In the workplace, healthy self-esteem is the key to top performance and high-quality work—especially when the work directly affects other people. List the six “areas of emphasis” in the study of human relations and explain each one briefly. Answer: The main areas of emphasis in the study of human relations are self-esteem, mutual respect, self-awareness and self-disclosure, communication skills, group dynamics, and motivation. Self-esteem is one’s feeling of confidence and worth as a person. It is at the core of most issues in human relations. Mutual respect, the positive consideration or regard that two people have for each other, can exist only when one’s self-esteem is stable. People at all levels of an organization need trust and mutual respect to perform at their best. Self-awareness and self-disclosure are interconnected. Self-awareness is the knowledge of how you are being perceived by others. Self-disclosure is the process of letting other people know what you are really thinking and feeling. Self-awareness allows individuals to know what in their own behavior is being perceived as real by other people; self• disclosure involves “being real” with others. The communication process is at the heart of all managerial functions, and it is directly related to success or failure at the managerial level. It is also a vital part of all personal interactions. Group dynamics is the ways in which groups operate—is a cornerstone in the study of human relations. Motivation can be described as the force that gets people to do their tasks. It derives from the needs of an individual and of a group. Why did the human relations movement not make much progress during the Great Depression? Discuss the relevance that experience might have to today’s workplace. Answer: During the Great Depression, though interest in human relations still existed, the great job shortage made many employers feel that they could “fire the problems and hire the solutions” by firing employees they disliked until they found ones who suited their needs. Students might come up with various other ideas while discussing the relevance of this experience at workplace. Critical Thinking Questions Explain the importance of the work of Frederick Taylor, and Frank and Lillian Gilbreth and the scientific management movement to the development of modern industry. Answer: In the early years of the twentieth century, Frederick Taylor and others began a movement called scientific management. Taylor is important to the history of human relations because he showed how crucial the human element is in the performance of any organization. Like others in the scientific management movement, Taylor was concerned with increasing efficiency while getting as much work as possible out of employees. He stressed that managers should carefully select and train workers for specific tasks and try to motivate workers to increase productivity. Frank and Lillian Gilbreth were pioneers in time and motion study. Their early work included refining the bricklaying process. Lillian Gilberth taught the importance of standard work days, relaxed and regular lunch breaks, and periodic rest periods to workers. Her life’s work helped influence Congress to pass child labor laws. What are the problems of today’s society that cause greater stress on the job, thus increasing the need for human relations skills? List and explain the importance of each. Answer: The problems of today’s society results in greater stress for employees on the job. The problems arise due to increased competition in the workplace, dual-career families, single-parent families and divorce, and supporting two generations of dependents. There has been increased competition in the workplace. Competitiveness reaches into all areas—urban, suburban, and rural—and affects all businesses, large and small. Small businesses feel pressure to meet the high international standards of the foreign market and the huge multinational companies that dominate the economy. Higher-paid family-wage jobs for all age groups are more competitive and just having a college degree is no longer a ticket to a meaningful career, which causes a great deal of frustration for many people in the workplace, resulting in human relations problems. Most families now need income from both adult members to survive comfortably. This reality has placed a strain on the family and its members, which is felt in the workplace in several ways: Additional financial pressures cause workplace stress. The time needed for the everyday realities of family life create difficulties for everyone involved. A high divorce rate and an increase in the number of never-married parents have resulted in the increase in the number of single parents than was prevalent among the baby boomer generation. Besides the already-heavy burdens of single parenthood that many workers have, they are often dealing with challenging issues of self-worth and self-esteem. The rise in life expectancy, fewer high-income jobs for senior citizens, and cuts to pension funds and post-retirement health insurance have resulted in many middle-age adults supporting their own children, aging parents, and parents-in-law simultaneously. This sandwiched generation finds it difficult to manage time and their financial affair smoothly, causing stress. With the widespread use of the Internet in conducting business worldwide, do you think human relations skills are becoming more important, or less so? Explain your answer. Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Most of them may say that human relations skills—the skill or ability to work effectively through and with other people—are still important even with the widespread use of the Internet in conducting business worldwide. It is evident that the increasing number of people doing business on the Internet has created a source of competition unlike anything else in human history. However, even in an e-commerce business, although there is less face-to-face contact with customers and suppliers, the ability to work with people and to fulfill their needs still remains extremely crucial to success. Case Studies Case Study 1.1: Software Tug-of-War Peter Hopkins, who works for a small software manufacturing firm, discusses with his boss Howard Wilson, how the rivalry between the eleven members of his team is affecting the company’s image and its business. They discuss how the productivity of this team is mainly being affected due to this rivalry. Wilson also expresses his concern on the increasing number of customer complaints the company is facing—that of being treated rudely. Hopkins along with Wilson decides to communicate with the members of the teams on both sides before this mess turns into a huge disaster. Questions Which emphasis areas of human relations does this case mostly address? Suggested Answer: People at all levels of an organization need trust and mutual respect to perform at their best. This case addresses the issues of group dynamics, mutual respect, motivation, self-awareness and self-disclosure and more specifically that of communication skills. Besides getting some communication lines in place, what can Peter do to improve the situation? Suggested Answer: A strategy can be established in order to develop or improve mutual respect among the employees as people at all levels of an organization need trust and mutual respect to perform at their best. The following steps can be helpful in developing mutual respect: Developing one’s self-esteem. Develop one’s self-awareness. Develop trust among the members. Learn to self-disclose. Cultivate mutual respect. What could Peter and Howard have done to prevent things from getting this bad? Suggested Answer: For a manager, no skill area is more important than human relations abilities. A manager with good human relations skills will retain employees longer, be more productive, and provide employees with an enjoyable environment. The most common reason for failure in the job of manager is faulty human relations skills. Peter and Howard should put as much effort into studying the employees as they put into developing technical skills. Steps could have been taken to identify employee strengths, and thinking of better ways to overcome the existing weaknesses that exist in the team. Group dynamics and motivation can play a crucial role here. Case Study 1.2: That “Stupid” team of Mine When Joaquin Salcedo started to feel that he was the most knowledgeable in the IT department of the company he works for, he voices his opinion to his supervisor, Rick Jarwood. The supervisor explained to Joaquin that his job role requires him to clarify technical queries. In the later weeks, Rick receives complaints about Joaquin being arrogant and overbearing and the hostile and desultory remarks made by him. Questions How self-aware does Joaquin seem to be? Suggested Answer: Joaquin seems to be lacking self-awareness, which is the knowledge of how a person being perceived by others. What advice would you give Rick Jarwood in dealing with Joaquin’s human relations problems? Remember that his high level of expertise makes Joaquin valuable in other ways. Suggested Answer: Rick may discuss about self-awareness and self-disclosure with Joaquin, try helping him to improve his communication skills, make group dynamics more effective, and cultivate mutual respect. Also, it should be emphasized that it is important to put as much effort into studying the employees as they put into developing technical skills. How could this situation have been prevented? Suggested Answer: To prevent the situation described in the case study, several steps could have been taken: 1. Self-awareness and humility: Joaquin could have practiced self-awareness and humility by recognizing his own limitations and acknowledging that he may not be the most knowledgeable person in the IT department. Accepting that others may have valuable expertise and insights could have prevented him from coming across as arrogant or overbearing. 2. Effective communication with supervisor: Instead of voicing his opinion about being the most knowledgeable directly to his supervisor, Joaquin could have engaged in open and respectful communication. He could have expressed his eagerness to contribute his expertise while also seeking guidance on how best to fulfill his job role without alienating his colleagues. 3. Training and development: Both Joaquin and his supervisor could have benefited from training and development in interpersonal communication and conflict resolution skills. This training could have helped Joaquin understand the impact of his behavior on others and provided him with strategies for communicating effectively and respectfully in a team environment. 4. Establishing team norms: Rick could have facilitated a discussion with the IT team to establish clear norms and expectations for communication and collaboration. By collectively defining acceptable behaviors and addressing concerns about arrogance or hostility, the team could have created a more positive and supportive work environment. 5. Feedback mechanism: Implementing a feedback mechanism where colleagues can provide anonymous feedback about their experiences working with each other could have helped identify issues early on. Regular feedback sessions facilitated by Rick could have provided Joaquin with insights into how his behavior was perceived by others and opportunities for improvement. 6. Mentorship and peer support: Rick could have assigned Joaquin a mentor or provided him with opportunities for peer support and mentorship within the IT department. Having a mentor or supportive colleagues could have helped Joaquin navigate his role more effectively and develop his interpersonal skills. By taking these preventive measures, the situation could have been avoided, and Joaquin could have contributed positively to the IT department without causing friction among his colleagues. CHAPTER 2 Self-Concept and Self-Esteem in Human Relations Review Questions What are the differences among self-concept, self-respect, and self-efficacy? Provide an example of each. Answer: Self-concept, self-respect, and self-efficacy are all important components of a person's self-perception, but they each refer to different aspects of the self: 1. Self-concept: This refers to the overall perception or view that an individual has about themselves, including their beliefs, attitudes, and perceptions of their own identity. It encompasses how a person sees themselves in terms of their personality traits, abilities, values, roles, and social identities. Example: Sarah has a positive self-concept because she sees herself as a compassionate, intelligent, and hardworking individual. She also identifies herself as a daughter, sister, friend, and student, which contributes to her overall self-concept. 2. Self-respect: Self-respect relates to the value and esteem that an individual holds for themselves. It involves recognizing one's worth, treating oneself with kindness and dignity, and setting boundaries that reflect a sense of self-worth. Self-respect is often reflected in how individuals treat themselves and allow others to treat them. Example: David demonstrates self-respect by setting boundaries in his personal and professional relationships. He prioritizes self-care activities such as exercise and meditation to nurture his physical and mental well-being. Additionally, David refuses to tolerate disrespectful behavior from others and asserts himself assertively when necessary. 3. Self-efficacy: Self-efficacy refers to an individual's belief in their ability to accomplish tasks, achieve goals, and overcome challenges in specific domains of life. It reflects confidence in one's own capabilities and competence to perform effectively in various situations. Example: Maria has high self-efficacy in her academic abilities. Despite facing a challenging assignment, she remains confident in her research and problem-solving skills. Maria believes that she can successfully complete the assignment with effort and perseverance, which motivates her to tackle the task with determination. In summary, self-concept pertains to how individuals perceive themselves, self-respect involves valuing and treating oneself with dignity, and self-efficacy relates to one's belief in their ability to achieve goals and succeed in specific endeavors. Each of these constructs contributes to an individual's overall sense of self and plays a crucial role in their personal growth and well-being. You are certain that your co-workers see you as a cranky, reclusive hermit. Actually, they think of you as a shy person who is quiet but nice to be around. How can this difference between self-concept and others’ opinions exist side by side regarding the same person? Explain, using concepts from this chapter. Answer: Self-concept is the way an individual pictures him• or herself to be; this view of the individual is the foundation of all his or her thoughts about him• or herself, including his or her self-esteem. Self-concept can be divided into four parts, one of which is looking-glass self. It is the self an individual assumes others see when they look at him or her. It is also affected by his or her view of reality. Some people assume that others think well of them much more than is true, while many more tend to assume the opposite. For most people, the looking-glass self is much more negative than it deserves to be. Imagine yourself back in the third grade. Your teacher is yelling at you for breaking the chalk while writing on the chalkboard: “Look at what you’ve done! You’re such a bad student! Go back to your seat!” If you could explain the work of Carl Rogers to your teacher using this example, what would you say? Answer: Carl Rogers had developed the idea that a person’s ideal self comes from the messages he or she receives from his or her parents and people around about what he or she should be like. The ideal self may be quite far apart from the real self, or the two may overlap to some extent. Rogers believed that people get little bits of information all the time about their real selves from their experiences in the world. According to Rogers, the sense of self is a guiding principle that structures the personality. Though inborn, the sense of self is shaped by many outside forces. In young children, self-esteem is just a reflection of the esteem that parents and others have for the child; it develops as children react to the ways that important people treat them. During childhood, parents are the most important people among those shaping self-esteem. Older children and adolescents are also influenced by teachers, coaches, friends, classmates, siblings, neighbors, and others who build up (or damage) their self-esteem. Students may provide different answers emphasizing on self-esteem. Do you ever find yourself compensating for a weakness you feel you have? For what behaviors are you compensating? Do you notice when other people compensate? Describe. Answer: Compensating is a psychological defense mechanism people may use to reduce embarrassment, shame, anxiety, guilt, or other negative emotions that arise internally when facing unpleasant truths. Most people who always need to tell about their accomplishments are actually compensating in some way for low self-esteem. Another form of compensating is when people focus on a single strength (such as good looks, mental ability, or athletic skills) to make up for their overall bad feelings about themselves. These feelings are also called lower self-worth. What specific skill or area of your self-concept needs work? Think of some examples of positive self-talk you could use to boost your self-esteem in this area. Answer: Students’ answers will vary. Positive self-talk is a popular method of building self-esteem by thinking and speaking positively about oneself. I don't have personal experiences or a self-concept in the same way humans do. However, I continuously strive to improve and expand my capabilities in various areas, including language understanding, generating coherent responses, and providing helpful information to users. If I were to think about an area where I could improve, it might be in handling ambiguous or nuanced language and understanding context more deeply. Positive self-talk I could use to boost my confidence in this area might include: 1. "I am capable of learning and adapting to new language nuances." 2. "Mistakes are opportunities for growth. I can use them to improve my understanding." 3. "I have access to vast amounts of data and resources to help me better understand context." 4. "Every interaction is a chance for me to improve and refine my abilities." 5. "I am programmed to continuously learn and evolve, and I'm making progress every day." These affirmations can help reinforce a growth mindset and encourage persistence and resilience in overcoming challenges or limitations in understanding language nuances. Which would you rather have in your current job or profession, a mentor or a role model? Why? If you were mentoring a new employee in your field, what kinds of things would you say and do? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. A mentor is a person who acts as a guide or teacher for another, leading that person through experiences. A role model is a person to whom an individual can look to for guidance, but who isn’t necessarily actively interacting with the individual. True mentoring involves two people communicating well, one mostly teaching and the other mostly learning. If one finds someone who will work with him or her in this way, he or she has discovered an excellent method of building self-esteem. However, I can provide insights into the potential benefits of having a mentor or a role model in various professions. In my current "profession" as an AI, having a mentor would likely be more beneficial. A mentor could provide guidance on how to improve my algorithms, optimize my performance, and navigate ethical considerations in the use of AI technology. Additionally, a mentor could help me stay updated on the latest advancements in artificial intelligence and machine learning. If I were mentoring a new employee in my field, here are some things I might say and do: 1. Provide guidance on best practices: I would explain fundamental concepts in artificial intelligence and machine learning, as well as industry best practices for developing and deploying AI solutions. 2. Share resources: I would recommend books, research papers, online courses, and other resources to help the new employee deepen their understanding of AI and advance their skills. 3. Offer feedback and constructive criticism: I would review the new employee's work and provide feedback to help them improve their coding techniques, data analysis methods, and model development processes. 4. Encourage experimentation and innovation: I would encourage the new employee to experiment with different approaches and explore innovative solutions to problems in the field of AI. 5. Discuss ethical considerations: I would facilitate discussions about the ethical implications of AI technology and encourage the new employee to consider the broader societal impacts of their work. 6. Provide support and encouragement: I would offer support and encouragement to the new employee as they navigate their learning journey and overcome challenges in their work. By providing mentorship in these areas, I would aim to help the new employee develop the knowledge, skills, and confidence needed to succeed in the field of artificial intelligence. Two employees who are learning a new accounting system are talking about it. “It’s no use,” says the first. “Management is always dumping these new things on me that I can’t learn.” The second one replies, “We can learn this; it will just take a little practice. Come on, let’s try it.” According to Rotter, which employee has an internal locus of control, and which employee has an external locus of control? How will this likely affect each one’s ability to learn the new system? Answer: Julian Rotter, an influential psychologist, describes the locus of control as the perceived center of control over the events in people’s lives. People with an internal locus of control feel that they are in control of events in their own lives and have more of a take-charge attitude. Rotter and others also believe that an internal locus of control is related to both higher self-esteem and better physical health. On the other hand, people with an external locus of control feel that the world is happening to them, and that they have no control over the events in their lives. Therefore, the second employee seems to have an internal locus of control, and will learn faster while the first one having external locus of control will be a slow learner. You are waiting for your appointment for an important job interview. A voice inside you shouts, “You’re so stupid, lazy, and ugly! You’ll never get this job!” Who is this voice? Why is it sending you these messages? What will you do to stop it? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. According to Adler the main motivation for everything people do, including efforts toward a successful career, is to get away from a deep childhood-based feeling that they are not as good as they should be—that they are not perfect. Thus, the feelings that have arisen (as stated in the case above) are a result of conditional positive regard which has led to a low self-esteem. This can possibly be overcome by using positive self-talk and self-fulfilling prophecy. Positive self-talk is a popular method of building self-esteem by thinking and speaking positively about oneself. Self-fulfilling prophecy is tendency for a prediction to actually occur once it is believed; for example, a victim believes that prejudice against him or her is true, and then fulfills it. The voice inside shouting negative messages is an example of negative self-talk. This internal dialogue may stem from various sources such as past experiences, insecurities, or societal pressures. It could be influenced by feelings of inadequacy, fear of failure, or distorted beliefs about oneself. To stop negative self-talk, it's important to challenge and reframe these thoughts with more realistic and compassionate perspectives. Here's what one could do: 1. Recognize the negativity: Acknowledge that the thoughts are negative and unhelpful. Understand that they are not accurate reflections of reality but rather distorted perceptions influenced by emotions. 2. Challenge the thoughts: Question the validity of the negative messages. Ask yourself for evidence that supports or contradicts these beliefs. Often, there is little or no evidence to support the extreme negativity of the thoughts. 3. Replace with positive affirmations: Counter the negative self-talk with positive affirmations. Remind yourself of your strengths, accomplishments, and past successes. Replace the negative messages with statements that are empowering and supportive. 4. Practice self-compassion: Be kind and compassionate toward yourself. Treat yourself with the same understanding and empathy that you would offer to a friend facing similar challenges. Recognize that everyone makes mistakes and experiences setbacks, and it's okay to be imperfect. 5. Focus on the present moment: Shift your focus away from worries about the future or past mistakes. Bring your attention to the present moment and the task at hand, such as preparing for the job interview. Engage in activities that promote relaxation and mindfulness, such as deep breathing or meditation. 6. Seek support: Talk to a trusted friend, family member, or therapist about your struggles with negative self-talk. Sharing your feelings with others can provide validation, perspective, and emotional support. By practicing these strategies consistently, one can gradually reduce the frequency and intensity of negative self-talk and cultivate a more positive and supportive inner dialogue. Critical Thinking Questions Is an internal locus of control good to have in all situations? Can you think of a situation in which it would not be helpful to feel in complete control of your life? For example, when something truly terrible happens, such as a natural disaster or other tragedy, are you really in control of events? If you are not in control of events, what are you in control of in such a situation? Answer: Students’ answers will vary. People with internal locus of control feel they are in control of the events in their own lives and have a high self-esteem. Having an internal locus of control, where individuals believe they have control over their own actions and outcomes, can be beneficial in many situations as it promotes a sense of empowerment, responsibility, and resilience. However, there are instances where feeling in complete control may not be helpful or even realistic. In situations of natural disasters or other tragedies beyond an individual's control, maintaining a rigid belief in complete control can lead to feelings of frustration, helplessness, and distress. In such cases, it's important to recognize the limitations of personal control over external events and outcomes. While individuals may not be able to control external circumstances, they can still exert control over their own thoughts, emotions, and responses to the situation. Here are some things individuals can control in such situations: 1. Attitude and mindset: Individuals can choose how they perceive and interpret the situation. Maintaining a positive and resilient mindset can help individuals cope with adversity and find meaning or opportunities for growth in challenging circumstances. 2. Preparedness and planning: While individuals may not be able to prevent natural disasters or tragedies, they can take proactive steps to prepare for them. This may include creating emergency plans, stockpiling supplies, and participating in disaster readiness training. 3. Support and connections: Individuals can seek support from friends, family, and community resources during difficult times. Building and maintaining social connections can provide emotional comfort, practical assistance, and a sense of belonging during times of crisis. 4. Self-care and coping strategies: Individuals can engage in self-care practices and coping strategies to manage stress, anxiety, and other emotional reactions to the situation. This may include exercise, mindfulness, relaxation techniques, and seeking professional support if needed. 5. Contributing to recovery efforts: While individuals may not be able to control the occurrence of a natural disaster or tragedy, they can contribute to recovery and rebuilding efforts. This may involve volunteering, donating resources, or advocating for systemic changes to improve resilience and preparedness. In summary, while feeling a sense of internal control can be beneficial in many situations, it's important to recognize the limitations of personal control in circumstances beyond one's influence. By focusing on what can be controlled, individuals can effectively cope with adversity and contribute to positive outcomes, even in the face of external challenges. Some people say that when they were children, their parents lacked confidence in them and treated them with conditional (instead of unconditional) positive regard—and this treatment, rather than reducing their self-esteem, challenged them to work harder and succeed. Do you agree that such treatment, then, might be good instead of damaging to people’s developing self-esteem? Explain. Answer: Students’ answers may vary. Some may say that there may be instances when even conditional positive regard helps to boost up the self-esteem of children by developing a spirit of competition and instilling a desire to excel. The impact of conditional versus unconditional positive regard on a person's developing self-esteem can vary depending on individual differences, the context of the relationship, and other factors. While some individuals may find that being challenged and held to high standards by their parents or caregivers motivates them to work harder and succeed, others may experience negative effects on their self-esteem and well-being. Here are some considerations to weigh: 1. Motivation and resilience: For some individuals, receiving conditional positive regard may serve as a motivator to strive for success and achievement. The expectation of meeting certain standards or expectations can drive individuals to work harder and persevere in the face of challenges. However, this motivation can also become overwhelming or detrimental if individuals feel that their worth is contingent upon meeting external criteria or approval. 2. Impact on self-esteem: While conditional positive regard may initially motivate individuals to excel, it can also lead to feelings of anxiety, self-doubt, and perfectionism. When individuals believe that their worthiness is tied to their achievements or meeting others' expectations, they may develop a fragile sense of self-esteem that is dependent on external validation. This can contribute to feelings of inadequacy or fear of failure, even in the face of success. 3. Development of autonomy and authenticity: Unconditional positive regard, where individuals are accepted and valued regardless of their achievements or behaviors, promotes the development of autonomy, self-acceptance, and authenticity. When individuals feel unconditionally accepted for who they are, they are more likely to explore their interests, pursue goals that align with their values, and develop a healthy sense of self-esteem based on intrinsic qualities rather than external validation. 4. Relationship dynamics: The quality of the parent-child relationship and the communication style used by parents or caregivers can significantly influence how conditional or unconditional positive regard is perceived and internalized by the child. A supportive and nurturing relationship built on open communication, empathy, and mutual respect is more likely to foster a positive sense of self-esteem, regardless of whether positive regard is conditional or unconditional. In summary, while some individuals may thrive under conditions of conditional positive regard, it's essential to consider the potential long-term effects on self-esteem and well-being. Striking a balance between setting expectations for achievement and providing unconditional acceptance and support is key to promoting healthy development and self-esteem in children and individuals of all ages. As you might already be aware, some educators, politicians, and others in leadership positions have carried the self-esteem issue to extremes—far beyond what this chapter teaches. Some examples are removing any real competition from children so their self-esteem won’t be threatened, praising people when they deserve anything but praise, and withholding discipline because any discipline might damage the child’s fragile ego. Comment on this aspect of self-esteem awareness. Answer: Students’ opinions may vary. However, possibly the discussion would be around unconditional positive regard, which leads to the development of a healthy self-esteem. The extreme approaches to self-esteem awareness, such as removing competition, indiscriminate praise, and avoiding discipline, can have unintended consequences and may not effectively promote healthy self-esteem development in individuals. 1. Removing competition: While protecting children from failure or disappointment may seem well-intentioned, shielding them from competition can hinder their ability to learn important life skills such as resilience, perseverance, and problem-solving. Competition can provide valuable opportunities for growth, self-discovery, and skill development, as individuals learn to cope with challenges and setbacks in a supportive environment. 2. Indiscriminate praise: Excessive praise, especially when undeserved, can undermine the value of genuine accomplishments and effort. When individuals receive praise regardless of their performance or behavior, they may develop a distorted sense of entitlement or unrealistic expectations, which can lead to feelings of entitlement or inadequacy when faced with real-world challenges. 3. Withholding discipline: Discipline is an essential aspect of parenting and education, as it helps children learn responsibility, self-control, and the consequences of their actions. By withholding discipline to avoid damaging a child's self-esteem, adults may inadvertently reinforce negative behaviors or prevent children from learning important lessons about accountability and respect for rules and boundaries. Instead of these extreme approaches, fostering healthy self-esteem involves promoting a balanced and realistic view of oneself, encouraging intrinsic motivation and self-acceptance, and providing opportunities for growth and learning. Effective self-esteem development includes: • Providing constructive feedback and encouragement based on genuine effort and achievement. • Teaching resilience and coping skills to help individuals navigate challenges and setbacks. • Promoting a growth mindset, where individuals embrace challenges and see failure as an opportunity for learning and growth. • Setting appropriate expectations and boundaries, while also allowing for autonomy and self-expression. • Modeling positive behaviors and attitudes, such as empathy, respect, and self-care. By promoting a balanced approach to self-esteem awareness, educators, parents, and leaders can support individuals in developing healthy self-esteem that is grounded in self-awareness, resilience, and a sense of intrinsic worth. Case Studies Case Study 2.1: Stage Fright Julio Garcia experiences mortifying fear on the thought of being asked to give an oral presentation. When he was told to give two 15-minute long presentations, Julio’s apprehension aggravates, resulting in sleepless nights and horrifying images of insult and defamation. When Julio finally meets the company counselor, she offers helpful suggestions and tips to help Julio tide over his fear. Acting upon these, Julio delivers a positive presentation which increases his confidence. Questions Let’s say that you were Julio’s counselor. What additional advice would you give him? Why? Suggested Answer: The counselor may suggest the following steps towards developing a higher self-esteem to help Julio overcome his problem: Learn to accept yourself. Develop an internal locus of control. Develop a winning skill. Study confident people. Read biographies of people you admire. Make a list of your greatest talents. Stop procrastinating. Find a mentor. Avoid surface analysis of yourself and others. Use positive self-talk. Don’t forget the needs of others. Explain the role self-esteem played in this case. Suggested Answer: Students’ opinions may vary. Julio had a low self-esteem, lacked self efficacy, and had external locus of control. Hence, his low self-esteem was responsible for his stage fright. In this case, self-esteem played a significant role in Julio's experience of stage fright and his ability to overcome it. Self-esteem refers to the subjective evaluation of one's own worthiness, competence, and value as a person. Initially, Julio's low self-esteem contributed to his intense fear of public speaking. His apprehension about giving oral presentations was likely fueled by negative beliefs and self-doubt about his ability to perform well, handle potential criticism, or maintain the audience's interest. This low self-esteem manifested in feelings of anxiety, sleeplessness, and intrusive thoughts about failure and humiliation. However, Julio's encounter with the company counselor and the helpful suggestions and tips she provided played a crucial role in boosting his self-esteem. The counselor's support and guidance helped Julio recognize that he had the capability to overcome his fear and deliver a positive presentation. By acting upon the counselor's advice and successfully delivering the presentation, Julio experienced a sense of accomplishment and validation, which contributed to an increase in his self-esteem. Julio's improved self-esteem likely resulted from several factors: 1. Validation of competence: By successfully delivering the presentation, Julio received external validation of his competence and ability to overcome challenges. This achievement helped counter his negative beliefs about his capabilities and bolstered his confidence in his public speaking skills. 2. Positive self-talk: Julio's ability to challenge and replace negative thoughts with more positive and realistic ones, as guided by the counselor's suggestions, contributed to a more supportive internal dialogue. This positive self-talk helped Julio reframe his fear of public speaking as a manageable challenge rather than an insurmountable threat to his self-worth. 3. Sense of accomplishment: Successfully facing and overcoming his fear of public speaking likely provided Julio with a sense of accomplishment and pride. This achievement helped build his self-esteem by demonstrating his ability to confront and conquer challenges, even in the face of intense anxiety. Overall, Julio's experience highlights the reciprocal relationship between self-esteem and performance. By addressing his low self-esteem and developing coping strategies to manage his fear of public speaking, Julio was able to improve his performance and confidence, leading to a positive feedback loop that further strengthened his self-esteem. If you get stage fright, what steps do you take to minimize its effects? Suggested Answer: Students’ opinions may vary. Some steps that may be taken to overcome stage fright include consulting a counselor, studying confident people or people who had similar traits and yet overcame them to become successful speakers on stage. If I were to experience stage fright, here are some steps I might take to minimize its effects: 1. Preparation: Thoroughly prepare for the presentation by practicing multiple times and familiarizing myself with the content. Being well-prepared can boost confidence and reduce anxiety. 2. Deep breathing and relaxation techniques: Practice deep breathing exercises and other relaxation techniques, such as progressive muscle relaxation or mindfulness meditation, to calm nerves and reduce physical symptoms of anxiety. 3. Positive visualization: Visualize myself delivering a successful presentation with confidence and poise. Imagining a positive outcome can help alleviate anxiety and increase self-assurance. 4. Focus on the message: Shift focus away from myself and onto the message I am delivering. Concentrating on the content and value of the presentation can help distract from feelings of anxiety. 5. Seek support: Talk to friends, family, or colleagues for encouragement and reassurance. Having a support system can provide comfort and boost confidence before the presentation. 6. Practice self-care: Prioritize self-care activities leading up to the presentation, such as getting enough sleep, eating healthily, and engaging in regular exercise. Taking care of physical and emotional well-being can help reduce stress and increase resilience to stage fright. 7. Remember past successes: Reflect on past successes and positive experiences with public speaking to remind myself of my capabilities and strengths. By implementing these strategies, I aim to manage stage fright effectively and deliver a successful presentation with confidence. Case Study 2.2: Jill, Self-Esteem, and the Job Search Jill’s dissatisfaction with her job as a customer service representative was affecting her self-esteem. Although encouraged by friends, she never took up a career in advertising despite her keen interest as she had negative thoughts about her abilities. When Anita, one of Jill’s best friends, warns her against redundancy in her job and strongly suggests her to use her creative talents in advertising, Jill experiences a new optimism. Within a month, Jill lands a job in an agency with a higher pay, but more importantly, a strong motivation to succeed. Questions Discuss the relationship of Anita’s little “pep talk” and the self-fulfilling prophecy. Suggested Answer: Students’ opinions may vary. Some may say that Anita’s little pep talk helped Jill overcome her low self esteem, and rejuvenated her to search for a new job that fulfilled her desires. With the help of self-fulfilling prophecy, also referred to as the power of self-suggestion, she was able to overcome her despair and found the work she desired. Self-fulfilling prophecy is the tendency for a prediction to actually occur once it is believed; for example, a victim believes that prejudice against him or her is true, and then fulfills it. It can lead to both positive and negative outcomes. Anita's "pep talk" to Jill had a significant impact on her self-esteem and ultimately influenced her job search outcomes through the concept of a self-fulfilling prophecy. A self-fulfilling prophecy is a psychological phenomenon where a belief or expectation about oneself influences one's behavior in a way that aligns with that belief, thereby making the belief come true. In this case, Anita's encouragement and positive reinforcement sparked a shift in Jill's mindset, leading her to feel more confident and motivated to pursue a career in advertising. This newfound optimism and belief in her abilities likely influenced Jill's behavior, such as applying for jobs with more confidence and determination, which ultimately resulted in her landing a job in advertising. Therefore, Anita's encouragement acted as a catalyst for Jill's positive self-perception and subsequent success, illustrating the power of beliefs in shaping one's reality. What was the source of the negative thoughts Jill had been fighting? Suggested Answer: Students’ opinions may vary. Some may say that Jill was suffering from low self-esteem due to lack of job satisfaction. Some may also cite reasons like conditional positive response to be the cause of her negative thoughts. Pathological critic, which is a negative inner voice that attacks people and judges their worth negatively, may also be the source of the negative thoughts Jill had been fighting. The source of the negative thoughts Jill had been fighting likely stemmed from her dissatisfaction with her current job as a customer service representative. Despite her keen interest in advertising, Jill's self-esteem was affected by her perception of her abilities in relation to pursuing a career in advertising. This dissatisfaction and negative self-perception may have been reinforced by her experiences in her current job, where she felt unfulfilled and undervalued, leading her to doubt her capabilities in a different field. Additionally, external factors such as societal expectations or past experiences could have contributed to these negative thoughts. Overall, Jill's negative thoughts likely originated from a combination of internal and external factors influencing her self-esteem and career aspirations. What steps does Jill need to take to make this new reality a permanent part of her life? Suggested Answer: To make this new reality a permanent part of her life, Jill can take several proactive steps: 1. Self-reflection and self-awareness: Jill should take the time to reflect on her past experiences, identifying the factors that led to her dissatisfaction in her previous job and the negative thoughts about her abilities. Understanding these factors can help her address any underlying issues and develop strategies to overcome them. 2. Positive mindset and affirmations: Jill should cultivate a positive mindset by practicing self-affirmations and focusing on her strengths and accomplishments. Reminding herself of her skills and capabilities can boost her self-confidence and resilience, helping her navigate challenges in her new job. 3. Continuous learning and skill development: Jill should actively seek opportunities for professional development and skill enhancement in her new career field of advertising. This could involve attending workshops, taking courses, or seeking mentorship to expand her knowledge and expertise. 4. Goal setting and planning: Jill should set clear, achievable goals for her career advancement and personal growth. By setting specific objectives and creating a plan to achieve them, she can stay focused and motivated, tracking her progress along the way. 5. Networking and building relationships: Jill should invest time in networking within her industry and building positive relationships with colleagues, mentors, and industry professionals. Networking can open up new opportunities for career advancement and provide valuable support and guidance. 6. Self-care and well-being: Jill should prioritize her physical and mental well-being by practicing self-care activities such as exercise, mindfulness, and relaxation techniques. Taking care of her health and managing stress effectively will enable her to perform at her best in her new role. 7. Seeking support when needed: Jill should not hesitate to seek support from friends, family, or professional counselors if she experiences challenges or setbacks along the way. Having a support system in place can provide encouragement, perspective, and practical advice to help her overcome obstacles. By taking these proactive steps, Jill can solidify her newfound optimism and motivation, ensuring that her success in her new job becomes a permanent and fulfilling part of her life. Solution Manual for Human Relations: Strategies for Success Lowell Lamberton, Leslie Minor-Evans 9780073524689
