Chapter 3 Planning for Human Resources LEARNING OBJECTIVES After reading this chapter, students should be able to: • Understand how human resource planning contributes to a firm’s competitive advantage. • Explain why and how firms engage in strategic planning. • Explain why and how human resource planning activities are conducted. • Describe how HRM practices are developed in response to an HR plan. • Understand the role of human resource information systems in planning and other HRM practices. CHAPTER OUTLINE AND LECTURE 3-1 Gaining Competitive Advantage Chapter one introduced the concept of gaining a competitive advantage. Here we will go into further details about how to make this a reality. 3-1a Opening Case: Gaining Competitive Advantage at General Motors General Motors found that its vast number of employees spent too much time completing paperwork and meeting with HR professionals about various HR transactions. This time expenditure hurt the workers productivity. GM addressed the issue by putting many of its HR activities online and creating an Employee Services Center website. The purpose was to allow all employees to complete certain HR services through the Internet. This new system enabled GM to save a significant amount of time and money. By costing less than a nickel a minute, as opposed to $2 a minute, and reducing the time spent by both the regular employees and HR employees, the website allows employees to be more productive, improving the speed and quality of their work. 3-1b Linking Human Resource Planning to Competitive Advantage American companies must now operate in a rapidly changing business environment that has implications for HRM practices. Human resource planning has become a necessity to tie HR issues to the organization’s business needs. HR planning helps firms anticipate their future HRM needs and identify practices that will help them meet those needs. HR planning is “the thread that ties together all other human resource activities and integrates these with the rest of the organization.” Figure 3-1 provides an example of how a firm’s HRM practices can be integrated with the goals of an organization. Successful implementation of many HRM practices depends on careful HR planning. Exhibit 3-1 in the text illustrates how the use of HR planning enables companies to gain control of their future by preparing for events that are likely to occur. By capitalizing on future events, management learns how to improve the future of its organization. Some companies ignore this planning, while others see it as too difficult or frustrating or simply do not see the need for it. By failing to plan, companies are forced to become reactive rather than proactive. A common failure associated with a lack of planning is becoming understaffed. As a consequence, current employees may experience undue stress. Firms may experience an increase in back orders, thus resulting in frustrated customers, increase in competition, or a loss of market share. Ask students to cite some examples of companies that failed to take advantage of its HR. Generate a discussion of what could have been done if they were in management. 3-2 HRM Issues and Practices Use this section to help students become more aware of both short-term and long-term HRM issues and practices. Ask a successful business person to attend class and present the old topic, “When we fail to plan, we plan to fail.” 3-2a Strategic Planning To get where you want to go, you must know where you are going. HRM practitioners must assist upper management in generating the overall, long-term, big picture of the organization. To do this, management must establish an organizational mission statement that explains its overall purpose. Next, the firm’s external and internal environments must be scanned to identify the threats and opportunities each poses. The CEO and functional department managers can provide this information. Next, the organization must set strategic goals that will allow it to carry out its mission. Finally, the strategic plan specifies the courses of action the firm must take to meet its strategic goals. 3-2b Human Resource Planning Through the HR planning process, an organization is able to create a list of future human resource needs and a plan for meeting them. First, the firm forecasts its future demand for human resources and then forecasts the supply of employees. The difference between the two forecasts signifies the firm’s HR needs. There are two general approaches to demand forecasting: statistical and judgmental. A statistical approach to demand forecasting is used when an organization operates in a stable environment. Using a statistical approach, an organization predicts needed workforce size on the basis of certain business factors. Business factors such as sales volume or market share closely relate to the size of the needed workforce. Commonly used statistical approaches include: • Trend analysis—Projects needs based on past business trends regarding a business factor. • Ratio analysis—Computes the exact ratio between the specific business factor and the number of employees needed. • Regression analysis—A statistically more sophisticated method where forecasts are based on the relationship between a business factor and workforce size. Statistical methods of demand forecasting assume that the relationship between workforce size and the business factor remains constant over time. Point out to students to watch for unexpected changes that will alter the forecast. Judgmental approaches include: • Group brainstorming—Occurs when a panel of “experts” generate a forecast in collaboration. • Sales force estimate—Requires sales personnel to estimate the demand for new products based on their knowledge of customer needs and interests. Tell students to remember that these approaches contain human error because they are estimates based on opinions and experience. Have students brainstorm a list of the two methods, which in their opinion will produce the most accurate results. If they used 2 or 3 methods in combination, which would they be and why? Supply forecasting estimates which organization positions will be filled at some future point in time. To accomplish this, the firm firstly groups its positions by title, function, and level of responsibility. The second step is to estimate, within each job group, how many will remain in their current positions, how many will move to other positions, and how many will leave the firm. Firms should also take into account plans for mergers, acquisitions, divestitures of units or divisions, layoffs, retrenchments and downsizings, and hostile takeovers. Firms should also consider individuals with known plans and use a computerized statistical package to help estimate the flow of employees. In the end, a firm derives its specific staffing needs by combining the results of the supply and demand forecast within each job group. 3-2c Outcomes of the HR Planning Process When the HR planning process is completed, a firm must establish and implement HRM practices to help it meet its human resource needs. When an oversupply of employees exists, downsizing is the step usually taken. This can take the form of layoffs, hiring freezes, early retirements, restricted overtime, job sharing, or pay reductions. When an undersupply of employees exists, a firm can hire additional workers internally or externally. Alternatives include improving productivity through additional training, overtime, additional shifts, job reassignments, temporary workers, improving retention rates, and providing appropriate management training. If the class is prepared, divide it into teams of 3 or 4 people. Assign each team with one of the forms of dealing with an oversupply of employees or one of the forms of dealing with an undersupply of employees. Appoint a spokesperson from each group to explain and defend its plan. 3-2d Human Resource Information Systems Every organization needs a good computerized human resource information system, or HRIS. It provides management with increased capacity to record, store, manipulate, and communicate information across wide geographic boundaries, with access to many users. An HRIS stores detailed information about jobs and employees. Purposes served can include: • Make budget-related calculations • Report turnover rates by department • Track external candidates • Track employee participation in each benefit option • Track accruals of vacation days and sick leave Let students use the Internet to look for additional ways in which an HRIS can improve a company’s performance. Also ask them to contact major employers in the area for this same information. Many companies are expanding their HR information systems by adding intranet and extranet capabilities. The intranet networks are accessible to people within a company. The extranet links a company’s intranet to outside organizations and vendors. Management must ensure the confidentiality and privacy of HRIS information or face the consequences. 3-3 The Manager’s Guide Line and department managers must be trained in HR planning, HR skill-building, and coordinating with the HR professionals. The three sections that follow provide some valuable insight into all three of these. 3-3a HR Planning and the Manager’s Job One of the line manager’s most important responsibilities is to ensure that his or her work unit is properly staffed at all times. To do this, the line manager must be able to accurately forecast the volume of work to be completed during the upcoming period and devise a work schedule to accomplish it. Line managers must play a crucial role in retaining employees. They can do this by establishing good working relationships with them and by treating them in a fair and equitable manner, while exhibiting concern for their well-being. People skills of being effective teachers, motivators, and communicators are especially important. Set up a panel of 5 student “experts” and place in front of the class. Let them have 10–12 minutes to discuss how they would keep a department properly staffed and retain employees. During this time let the rest of the class review this topic and make a list of 10 specific questions, 5 on each topic, to ask the students. 3-3b How the HR Department Can Help The HR department can help in three ways. • HR professionals help the strategic planning team with shaping and implementing the overall business strategy. They assist top management with understanding the HR implications of strategic decisions. • HR people also assist in implementing management initiatives. The corporate culture must be considered prior to implementing HRM programs. • The HR department plays a vital role in evaluating all HR plans and specific practices. 3-3c HRM Skill-Building for Managers The key to planning future needs is active, frequent, and open communications between all areas at work. Information about the future needs and workforce demands of a unit will better enable the HRM department to identify, select, and train current and future workers as needed. The most direct approach to getting this information is for line and functional managers to meet regularly with HR professionals, top managers, and other line managers. KEY TERMS Business factors: Attributes of a business, such as sales volume or market share, that closely relate to the size of the needed workforce. Corporate culture: The pattern of shared values, mores, and behaviors that separate one organization from others who are operating in the same industry. Demand forecasting: A process used in HR planning that entails predicting the number and types of people the organization will need at some future point in time. Extranet: Technology that links a company’s intranet to outside organizations and vendors. Group brainstorming: A technique of demand forecasting in which a panel of “experts” generate a forecast in collaboration. Human resource information system (HRIS): A computerized information package that provides management with increasing capacity to record, store, manipulate, and communicate information to users. Intranet: Internet networks that are accessible to people within a company. Mission statement: A declaration of the organization’s overall purpose. Ratio analysis: A process used in HR planning to determine future HR demand by computing an exact ratio between the specific business factor and the number of employees needed. Regression analysis: A statistical tool used in HR planning to determine the number of employees needed by a company at some future point in time. Sales force estimates: A technique of demand forecasting in which sales personnel are asked to estimate the demand for a new product based on their knowledge of customer needs and interests. Strategic goals: The desired outcomes that must be reached for the firm to accomplish its mission. Strategic plan: A plan that specifies the courses of action a firm must take in order to meet its strategic goals. Strategic planning: A process in which a company specifies its overall purposes and objectives, and indicates how these are to be achieved. Supply forecasting: A process used to estimate which organizational positions will be filled at some future point in time. Trend analysis: A process used in HR planning in which the future demand for human resources is projected on the basis of past business trends regarding a business factor. REVIEW QUESTIONS 1. HR planning is defined as a. a reactive method of dealing with human resource problems. b. a self-contained process that seeks to identify the strengths and weaknesses of human resource systems apart from general strategic planning. c. a process and a set of activities that attempts to respond to an organization’s need for human resources under changing conditions. d. the process by which resources (e.g., equipment, raw materials) are allocated to specific individuals (i.e., humans) in the work organization. Answer: c Rationale: HR planning is defined as the “process of identifying and responding to [organizational needs] . . . and charting new policies, systems, and programs that will assure effective human resource management under changing conditions.” 2. Which of the following steps is not a part of the strategic planning process? a. scanning the organizational environment b. setting strategic goals c. conducting a utility analysis d. determining the organizational mission Answer: c Rationale: It is through the strategic planning process that organizations determine where they are going. The strategic planning process typically consists of the following activities: • Determine the organizational mission. • Scan the organizational environment. • Set strategic goals. • Formulate a strategic plan, part of which addresses human resource needs. 3. Name one factor that organizational planners are attempting to assess when scanning the external environment for strategic planning purposes. a. the opportunities and threats posed by the competition b. the strengths and weaknesses of their own organization c. the supply of and demand for resources d. organizational culture and climate Answer: a Rationale: Organizational planners scan both the firm’s external and internal environments in order to identify the threats and opportunities each poses. Planners must also scan their industry environment to identify what their competitors are doing, what new firms may be entering the market, and what substitute products and services may be on the horizon. 4. A human resource need is defined as a. labor market conditions minus workforce skills. b. workforce demands minus labor market supply. c. management needs minus employee’s needs. d. the percentage of minority employees to the total labor force. Answer: b Rationale: To derive its human resource needs, the organization first forecasts its demand for human resources. It then forecasts its supply. The difference between the two forecasts signifies the firm’s HR needs. 5. Supply and demand forecasting are a. routine HR planning tools used by almost all organizations. b. dependent on government employment statistics to be completed accurately. c. combined to identify a firm’s specific staffing needs. d. more difficult to complete in times of business stability. Answer: c Rationale: Demand forecasting involves predicting the number and types of people the organization will need at some future point in time. Once a demand forecast has been made, the organization estimates which positions will be filled at a particular time. The process used to make this estimation is called supply forecasting. 6. Which of the following techniques would not be used to minimize the problems associated with oversupply of personnel? a. pay reductions b. job sharing c. layoffs d. training Answer: d Rationale: The current trend towards organizational restructuring usually results in a smaller workforce. The HRM response to this is usually downsizing, which usually means layoffs. Because of the negative outcomes that are often associated with layoffs, employers are encouraged to seek alternatives, such as hiring freezes, early retirements, restricted overtime, job sharing, pay reductions, and the like. 7. Organizations can improve employee retention by using all of the following except a. realistic job previews. b. training. c. quality of work life programs. d. scientific management. Answer: d Rationale: Instead of hiring new workers to meet increasing demands, an organization may decide to improve the productivity of the existing workforce through additional training. Retention rates are likely to improve when applicants are given a realistic preview of what their jobs would actually be like. Companies can also improve retention rates by creating a work environment that encourages employees to participate actively in the company’s total welfare. Workers want recognition for their contributions, but this recognition must be tailored to the individual employee. 8. A human resource information system is a. a computerized system that contains job and employee information including the work history, skills, and demographic characteristics of employees. b. a database containing standard operating procedures for performing work activities. c. a computerized system for tracking organizational indicators of productivity including downtime, profits, scrap, rework, and sales. d. a referral system that enables new employees to identify current employees who are most likely to have answers to their questions about the company. Answer: a Rationale: A human resource information system (HRIS) is a computerized information package that provides management with increasing capacity to record, store, manipulate, and communicate information across wide geographic boundaries, with access to many users. 9. To avoid violations of employee privacy when using human resource information systems, an organization should a. require new hires, as a condition of employment, to complete a form that allows free access to their records. b. limit access to sensitive and confidential records to those who have a “need to know.” c. allow each employee to decide which parts of his or her file may be reviewed by others in the organization. d. avoid storing information about a person’s strengths and development needs. Answer: b Rationale: Because many of the directories included in an HRIS contain highly sensitive data, the organization must ensure that user access is limited to relevant information. As a general rule, sensitive and confidential records should only be accessible by the HRM department or specified individuals. 10. Which of the following factors is not considered when using the group brainstorming approach to forecasting demand? a. future demands from the marketplace for the organization’s products and services b. the percentage of the market that the organization will serve c. the availability of employees with the skills needed to implement the strategic plan d. the availability and nature of new technologies that may affect the amounts and types of products or services that can be offered Answer: c Rationale: The group brainstorming technique of demand forecasting uses a panel of “experts.” They must examine the firm’s strategic plans for developing new products or services, expanding to new markets, and so forth, and then try to predict such things as: • Future demands from the marketplace for the organization’s products and services • The percentage of the market that the organization will serve • The availability and nature of new technologies that may affect the amounts and types of products or services that can be offered DISCUSSION QUESTIONS 1. Describe three ways in which effective HR planning can enhance a firm’s competitive advantage. • HR planning links HRM practices to organizational goals. • HR planning serves as a major building block for future HRM practices. • HR planning avoids consequences associated with the failure to plan for human resources. 2. Why do some companies avoid HR planning? What are the likely consequences when HR planning is omitted? • Some companies see HR planning as too difficult and frustrating. Others simply do not see the need for it. • When failing to plan properly for human resources, employers are forced to respond to events after they occur, rather than before; that is, they become reactive, rather than proactive. When this outcome occurs, an organization may be unable to correctly anticipate an increase in its future demand for employees. At best, such a company would be forced to recruit employees at the last minute and may thus fail to find the best candidate. At worst, the company may become seriously understaffed. 3. Describe the way in which an organization scans its environment. Why is this an important process? • The external environment is scanned to identify challenges posed by political, legal, economic, social, and technological issues. Planners must also scan their industry environment to identify what their competitors are doing, what new firms may be entering the market, and what substitute products and services may be on the horizon. • When scanning the internal environment, planners assess the firm’s strengths and weaknesses, because the firm’s strategic goals should be designed to take advantage of its strength and minimize its weaknesses. Key internal factors to consider include an organization’s culture, structure, current mission, past history, number of layers of management, span of control of management, skills of the human resources, leadership and power, and the number of functional areas. • Organizational planners must scan both the firm’s external and internal environments without fail in order to identify the threats and opportunities each poses. It is an important part of strategic planning process which has to be implemented to in order to reach a specific strategic goal. 4. Define the following terms: mission statement, strategic goal, and strategic plan. • Mission Statement—A declaration of the organization’s overall purpose. • Strategic Goal—The desired outcomes that must be reached for the firm to accomplish its mission. • Strategic Plan—A plan that specifies the courses of action a firm must take in order to meet its strategic goals. 5. What is the aim of demand forecasting? Briefly describe each of the methods of demand forecasting. • Demand forecasting is a process used in HR planning that entails predicting the number and types of people the organization will need at some future point in time. • The three methods of demand forecasting: ○ Trend analysis—A process used in HR planning in which the future demand for human resources is projected on the basis of past business trends regarding a business factor. ○ Ratio analysis—A process used in HR planning to determine future HR demand by computing an exact ratio between the specific business factor and the number of employees needed. ○ Regression analysis—A statistical tool used in HR planning to determine the number of employees needed by a company at some future point in time. 6. What is meant by “past mobility trends”? What bearing do they have on supply forecasting? • “Past mobility trends” in supply forecasting refers to the movement of employees through the organization. Specifically, how many current employees will remain in their position, how many will move to another position (e.g., through transfer, promotion, demotion), and how many will leave the organization. • By studying these trends, a company can predict how many of their projected future positions will be vacant. 7. What options does an organization have for dealing with predicted job vacancies? • The organization may decide to hire additional staff, but there are other options. • Instead of hiring new workers to meet increasing demands, and organization may decide to improve the productivity of the existing workforce through additional training. • Other options would be the use of overtime, additional shifts, job reassignments, or temporary workers. • Another option is to improve retention rates. 8. Describe three ways in which an organization can enhance its retention rates. • Retention rates can be improved at the outset of the employer/employee relationship, when applicants are first recruited. Retention rates are likely to improve when applicants are given a realistic preview of what their jobs would actually be like (warts and all), rather than an overly glowing one. • Organizations can cross-train employees to perform a variety of functions, thus ensuring that they have the necessary skills to continue to make ongoing contributions to the firm. Management training is also crucial. • Companies can create a work environment that encourages employees to participate actively in the company’s total welfare. • Companies can also offer attractive benefit packages, such as generous retirement plans, stock ownership, health and dental insurance, employee discount programs, and the like. 9. Describe the two types of data contained in an HRIS. • An HRIS contains information about a company’s jobs and employees. • The job file typically lists the number and types of jobs needed to achieve the organization’s strategic goals, the number of people needed in each job, and the qualifications needed to perform each job (based on job analysis information). • The employee file lists such information as an individual’s equal employment opportunity classification, date of hire, salary history, and performance ratings. A detailed list of other information in contained in Exhibit 3-4. 10. What are the advantages of using an HRIS as opposed to using a manual system? • An HRIS can handle most of the record keeping done by HR professionals, making it easier for these individuals to track compensation, payroll, benefits, insurance policies, career paths, and employee history. • An HRIS can reduce paperwork and cut administrative costs. • Organizational members outside the HRM department can more easily access the information. By providing such access, the administrative function of the HRM department can become more decentralized. 11. Describe the manager’s role with regard to HR planning. • One of the most important responsibilities of a line manager is to ensure that his or her work unit is properly staffed at all times. ○ To meet this responsibility, the manager must be able to accurately forecast the volume of work to be completed during the upcoming period and then devise a work schedule that assures the work can be completed competently and on schedule. • Line managers also play an important role in the area of employee retention, because their style of management can have a major impact on a subordinate’s decision to remain with the company. 12. Describe the role of the HR professional with regard to HR planning. • HR professionals help shape and implement overall business strategy. • They play a major role in the development and implementation of the firm’s HR plans. • HR professionals also evaluate plans to know if the HR strategies are effective.. EXPERIENTIAL EXERCISES Forecasting HR Demand for Installers A large kitchen cabinet and appliance distributor in the Southeast expects an increase in annual sales during the next 10 years from $1,500,000 to $2,250,000. In scanning its external environment, it notes that the local environment is changing: • Many new employees have entered the market area. • The population is aging; many are now “empty-nest” couples whose children have moved away. These individuals are remodeling their homes and seek larger, more expensive kitchens. • Many new families have entered the area who are budget conscious and want a kitchen to fit into their price range. • Building costs are steady. The HR planner for the kitchen distributor wants to forecast the requirements for installers for the next 10-year period. Because installers require 8 months of on-the-job training in addition to classroom instruction, an accurate forecast is needed. The CEO wants to use their own installers in the future rather than relying on the more expensive outside subcontractors. Mr. Rodriguez, the HR planner, decides to forecast HR demand by determining the relationship between the sales of the distributor and the number of installers required. He contacts several distributors of various sizes in the United States and obtains the following information: Sales in Millions ($) Number of Installers 1.0 4 1.5 7 2.0 9 2.5 15 3.0 17 Task 1. Plot these figures on a piece of graph paper. Estimate a regression line. That is, draw a line that cuts straight through the center of the points (one that minimizes the distance between the lines and the plotted points). 2. Using your plot, estimate the number of installers needed for forecasted sales of $2.25 million. 3. Given the trends and the nature of the industry, what other advice can you give the HR planner? Why might using the plotted information alone be risky? What other factors should Mr. Rodriguez consider? Why? CASE Succession Planning for Federal Express Corporation Objective: To make students aware of the consequences of sudden departures by high-level executives. The students should begin to appreciate the importance of avoiding turnover, while having a contingency plan (i.e., succession plan) in place. What to do: Analyze this case after your discussion on supply forecasting. Questions 1. Why do you think these individuals resigned? Student answers may vary as they may provide their opinion on why two of the top executives resigned. However, discussion should include coverage of ethics issues, retention of employees, and measuring employee satisfaction. • There are many reasons why these individuals resigned and they may not be the reasons given to management. Any time there is an increase in turnover in an organization, especially in upper level positions, it is important to investigate the work environment, strategic changes in the organization, change in the culture and working environment, and other organizational factors that may be contributing to a hostile or uncomfortable work environment. Carole Presley may indeed want to begin a consulting business and may have been planning it for some time. But due to changes in the organization and the losses internationally and drop in corporate earnings, she may have feared her job security and decided to get out of the company early, and thus the sudden decision. Thomas Oliver may have been contacted by VoiceCom Systems Inc. or by a head-hunter for the organization with a great job offer and salary increase or responsibility increase he could not refuse. Or like Carole, he saw a good time to leave the company during all the uncertainty and problems and had been actively looking for another job for some time. Suggest the value of exit interviews to determine problems and issues that need to be corrected to prevent future and sudden turnover at this level. 2. Outline a plan the organization can take to avoid future problems of this nature. Students are required to understand the case with the help of contents described under Section 3-2c Outcomes of the HR Planning Process. Alternatives to Additional Hiring can also be referred. • To avoid future problems of this nature, an organization must try to make the working environment attractive for employees. Assurances of their value and job security, even during lean and uncertain times, are critical to maintain morale and productivity. Frequent communication on the state of the organization and role of upper and middle management, by top management, is also important. At the same time, succession planning should be in place, particularly for key upper management positions. Replacements should be identified and proper training schedules in place so as to minimize the impact of the loss of management talent. Finally, organizations should carefully monitor turnover at all levels and attempt to determine the reasons through exit interviews and other employee surveys. 3. How will overall strategic planning for the short-term and long-term future of the firm be influenced by these resignations? Students could provide their opinion on whether the overall strategic planning for the short-term and long-term future of the firm be influenced by the resignation of the top two executives. • Overall strategic planning may suffer because of these resignations. Any existing programs and projects in place, headed by the exiting executives, will be halted or abandoned. Projects in both customer operations and marketing and corporate communications as well as day-to-day issues will be slowed or strained with new leadership not trained in these key areas. The long-term future of the firm will be less affected by the resignations, but top management and the HR department must still work to improve succession planning, as well as try to identify and correct the causes of the turnover. With the sudden and immediate resignations and departures, the new replacement to Mr. Oliver will have to act quickly to learn the new area. As no replacements for Carole A. Presley were announced, her staff will have to take over and assume her duties and responsibilities. The international replacement to Mr. Oliver, William Razzouk will also be torn between his past duties and his new responsibilities, thus causing short-term problems. CRITICAL THINKING EXERCISES 1. Ask students to cite some examples of companies that failed to take advantage of its HR. Generate a discussion of what could have been done if they were in management. 2. Ask a successful business person to attend class and present on the old topic, “When we fail to plan, we plan to fail.” 3. Have students brainstorm a list of the two methods, which in their opinion will produce the most accurate results. If they used 2 or 3 methods in combination, which would they be and why? 4. If the class is prepared, divide it into teams of 3 or 4 people. Assign each team with one of the forms of dealing with an oversupply of employees or one of the forms of dealing with an undersupply of employees. Appoint a spokesperson from each group to explain and defend its plan. 5. Let students use the Internet to look for additional ways in which an HRIS can improve a company’s performance. Also, ask them to contact major employers in the area for this same information. 6. Set up a panel of 5 student “experts” and place them in front of the class. Let them have 10–12 minutes to discuss how they would keep a department properly staffed and retain employees. During this time, let the rest of the class review this topic and make a list of 10 specific questions, 5 on each topic, to ask the students. ESSAY QUESTIONS 1. How did General Motors gain a competitive advantage and link it to HR planning? General Motors (GM) gained a competitive advantage through several key strategies linked to HR planning: 1. Workforce Transformation: GM invested in employee training and development, equipping workers with skills to adapt to new technologies and production methods, thereby enhancing productivity and innovation. 2. Diversity and Inclusion: The company implemented initiatives to promote diversity, fostering a more inclusive workplace that attracted a broader talent pool and improved problem-solving. 3. Strategic Workforce Planning: GM aligned its HR planning with business objectives by forecasting future workforce needs and proactively addressing talent gaps, ensuring the right skills were in place to meet market demands. 4. Employee Engagement Programs: GM focused on enhancing employee morale and engagement through recognition programs and open communication, which contributed to higher retention rates and a more committed workforce. By integrating these HR strategies, GM was able to respond effectively to market changes, improve operational efficiency, and maintain a competitive edge in the automotive industry. 2. Write a six-page treatise on how to gain a competitive advantage, HRM issues and practices contained in this chapter, and the manager’s guide. Gaining Competitive Advantage through HRM Practices Introduction To thrive in a competitive business landscape, organizations must leverage effective Human Resource Management (HRM) practices that enhance performance and drive innovation. Key Strategies for Competitive Advantage 1. Talent Acquisition and Retention: • Utilize strategic recruitment and competitive compensation to attract and retain top talent. 2. Employee Development: • Invest in ongoing training and clear career pathways to foster skill enhancement and loyalty. 3. Performance Management: • Implement outcome-based evaluations and regular feedback mechanisms to boost productivity and morale. 4. Organizational Culture: • Promote diversity and an inclusive environment to cultivate innovation and employee engagement. HRM Issues 1. Workforce Planning: • Address talent shortages and implement effective succession planning to ensure leadership continuity. 2. Legal and Ethical Challenges: • Stay compliant with employment laws and address ethical dilemmas to maintain a positive image. 3. Technological Integration: • Leverage HR technology for efficiency while ensuring data privacy and proper implementation. Manager’s Guide 1. Align HR Strategy: Connect HR practices to organizational goals. 2. Invest in Development: Prioritize training to meet current and future needs. 3. Enhance Communication: Foster open channels for feedback and engagement. 4. Measure Effectiveness: Use KPIs to assess HR impact on performance. 5. Promote Diversity: Implement policies that support an inclusive workforce. 6. Prepare for Change: Stay adaptable to industry trends and workforce dynamics. Conclusion By focusing on strategic HRM practices and addressing key issues, managers can drive competitive advantage and enhance overall organizational performance. 3. Explain how HR planning serves as a building block for future HR practices. HR planning serves as a foundational building block for future HR practices in several key ways: 1. Alignment with Organizational Goals: HR planning ensures that the workforce strategy aligns with the organization’s long-term objectives, facilitating targeted recruitment and development. 2. Anticipating Needs: By analyzing current and future workforce needs, HR planning helps identify skill gaps and staffing requirements, allowing organizations to proactively address them. 3. Resource Allocation: Effective HR planning aids in allocating resources efficiently, ensuring that training, development, and recruitment efforts are focused where they are most needed. 4. Improving Talent Management: It establishes frameworks for succession planning and talent management, enabling organizations to nurture and retain high-potential employees. 5. Adaptability to Change: HR planning prepares organizations to adapt to changing market conditions and workforce trends, fostering resilience and agility. By laying this groundwork, HR planning enhances the effectiveness of subsequent HR practices, driving overall organizational success. 4. Outline the benefits of HR forecasting. Benefits of HR Forecasting 1. Proactive Workforce Planning: • Anticipates future staffing needs, allowing organizations to address potential skill gaps before they impact operations. 2. Improved Recruitment Strategies: • Helps identify the types and numbers of employees required, leading to more targeted and efficient recruitment efforts. 3. Enhanced Talent Management: • Supports succession planning and talent development initiatives by predicting future leadership and skill requirements. 4. Cost Efficiency: • Reduces costs associated with overstaffing or understaffing by aligning workforce size with actual needs. 5. Informed Decision-Making: • Provides data-driven insights that enable managers to make strategic HR decisions based on projected trends and workforce dynamics. 6. Increased Organizational Agility: • Enhances the organization’s ability to respond to changes in the market or industry by ensuring a ready and capable workforce. 7. Employee Satisfaction and Retention: • By ensuring appropriate staffing levels and development opportunities, HR forecasting can lead to higher employee morale and lower turnover rates. These benefits collectively contribute to a more efficient, effective, and responsive HR function within organizations. 5. Provide an example of how a firm can accomplish the four-step strategic planning process. Example of a Firm's Four-Step Strategic Planning Process Company: XYZ Tech Solutions 1. Define Vision and Mission: • Mission: "To innovate and provide cutting-edge software solutions." • Vision: To lead the tech industry with a focus on customer satisfaction and employee development. 2. Conduct SWOT Analysis: • Strengths: Strong R&D team, established customer base. • Weaknesses: Limited market presence in emerging regions. • Opportunities: Growing demand for remote work solutions. • Threats: Intense competition. 3. Set Strategic Goals: • Expand into two new regions within a year. • Launch a new software product for remote teams by Q3. 4. Implement and Monitor: • Implementation: Assign teams for product development and regional marketing. • Monitoring: Use KPIs to track progress and conduct quarterly reviews. This process aligns XYZ Tech’s resources with its strategic objectives effectively. 6. Distinguish between the statistical and judgmental forecasting methods of demand forecasting. Distinction Between Statistical and Judgmental Forecasting Methods 1. Statistical Forecasting: • Definition: Utilizes mathematical models and historical data to predict future demand. • Approach: Relies on quantitative data analysis, including time series analysis and regression models. • Advantages: Objective, data-driven, and can identify trends and patterns over time; suitable for large datasets. 2. Judgmental Forecasting: • Definition: Based on subjective assessments and expert opinions rather than quantitative data. • Approach: Involves gathering insights from managers, salespeople, and market analysts to make informed predictions. • Advantages: Useful when data is scarce or unreliable; can incorporate qualitative factors and insights about market trends. In summary, statistical forecasting is data-driven and objective, while judgmental forecasting relies on human intuition and expertise. 7. How does your text suggest we go about forecasting the supply of future workers? To forecast the supply of future workers, the text suggests the following steps: 1. Analyze Current Workforce Data: Assess the existing workforce demographics, skills, and turnover rates to establish a baseline. 2. Identify Labor Market Trends: Research external factors such as economic conditions, industry growth, and demographic shifts that may impact labor supply. 3. Project Future Needs: Estimate future workforce requirements based on organizational goals and anticipated changes in demand for products or services. 4. Evaluate Training and Development: Consider the potential for upskilling current employees and the impact of educational institutions in producing qualified candidates. 5. Use Quantitative and Qualitative Methods: Combine statistical data with expert judgment to create a comprehensive view of future labor supply. This approach allows organizations to anticipate workforce availability and align their HR strategies accordingly. 8. In this scenario, you are faced with an oversupply of employees. One of your friends works for a direct competitor of yours and is faced with an undersupply of employees. Compile a list of all of the things you could do in either situation. Actions for Oversupply of Employees 1. Voluntary Separation: Offer incentives for voluntary resignations or early retirements. 2. Reduce Hours: Implement reduced work hours or job sharing. 3. Reassignment: Reassign employees to other departments or roles. 4. Training: Upskill employees for different roles or emerging needs. 5. Temporary Layoffs: Consider short-term layoffs with the option to return. 6. Hiring Freeze: Freeze new hires to manage the current workforce. Actions for Undersupply of Employees 1. Enhance Recruitment: Use targeted recruiting campaigns to attract talent. 2. Increase Compensation: Offer competitive salaries and benefits. 3. Referral Programs: Encourage employee referrals with bonuses. 4. Flexible Work: Promote remote work and flexible hours. 5. Educational Partnerships: Collaborate with schools for internship programs. 6. Employer Branding: Improve company reputation to attract candidates. These strategies effectively address either situation. 9. Compose a proposal letter to top management explaining why your company needs a computerized HRIS. Include the types of data it would contain, the purposes it would serve, and why it would be connected to an intranet and extranet. [Your Name] [Your Position] [Company Name] [Date] [Recipient Name] [Recipient Title] [Company Name] Dear [Recipient Name], Proposal for a Computerized HRIS I propose implementing a computerized Human Resource Information System (HRIS) to enhance our HR operations and efficiency. Data to Include • Employee profiles • Payroll and benefits information • Attendance and leave records • Performance evaluations • Recruitment data Purposes 1. Streamlined Operations: Automate payroll, benefits, and attendance tracking. 2. Centralized Data Management: Improve access to employee information for better decision-making. 3. Compliance: Maintain accurate records for labor law adherence. 4. Enhanced Communication: Offer employee self-service options for better engagement. Connectivity Integrating the HRIS with our intranet will allow employees to access information easily, while extranet connectivity will facilitate secure collaboration with external stakeholders, like recruitment agencies. This investment will lead to significant time and cost savings and support our strategic goals. I look forward to discussing this further. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, [Your Name] [Your Contact Information] 10. Why are staffing and retention so important for line managers? How can managers gauge future human resource needs? Importance of Staffing and Retention for Line Managers 1. Operational Efficiency: Effective staffing ensures that the right number of employees with the appropriate skills are in place to meet operational demands, leading to smoother workflows. 2. Employee Morale: Retention of skilled employees fosters a positive work environment, reducing turnover-related disruptions and maintaining team cohesion. 3. Cost Management: High turnover can be costly due to recruitment, training, and lost productivity. Retaining employees helps control these expenses. 4. Performance and Productivity: A well-staffed team is more likely to meet performance targets, enhancing overall productivity and contributing to organizational success. Gauging Future Human Resource Needs 1. Workforce Analysis: Assess current employee skills and performance levels to identify gaps and future needs. 2. Business Forecasting: Analyze market trends, business growth projections, and changes in demand to anticipate staffing requirements. 3. Turnover Rates: Monitor turnover trends to predict future hiring needs based on historical data. 4. Employee Feedback: Gather insights from employees about their roles and workloads to identify potential staffing challenges. By focusing on staffing and retention, line managers can ensure their teams are effective and aligned with organizational goals. OTHER RESOURCES I. Websites www.hr-guide.com. This is an HR Internet guide. II. Articles Content to Order, B. Roberts, HR Magazine, July 2002, pp. 79–83. Insight is provided into establishing order in the HR planning process. Extranets: Linking Employees with Your Vendors, S. Greengard, Workforce, November 1997, pp. 28–34. The advantage of using this modern form of communication is clearly outlined to improve performance between employees and vendors. Human Resource Management, Information Technology, and Competitive Edge, R. Broderick and J. W. Boudreau, Academy of Management Executive, 1992, 6 (2) pp. 7–17. This article explains how to link information technology and competitive edge to HRM. Increase the Value of Your Intranet, S. Greengard, Workforce, March 1997, pp. 88–94. The author provides us some valuable tips on increasing the value of intranets. Integrated Data Supports AT&T’s Succession Planning, V.J. Brush, and R. Nardoni, Personnel Journal, September 1992, pp. 103–109. Explains the common elements that characterize effective succession planning systems. Taking HR to the Next Level, B. Leonard, HR Magazine, July 2003, Vol. 48 No. 7. See this article to understand Leonard’s advice on how effective HR produces demonstrable result. III. Books The Practice of Management, P.F. Drucker, New York: Harper and Brothers, 1954. IV. Software Main Sequence Technologies is a source for software related to the topics in this chapter. Contact the company at [email protected] or call 440-946-5214. Solution Manual for Human Resource Management: A Managerial Tool for Competitive Advantage Lawrence S. Kleiman 9781426649189
Download
Close
Close
